+1(514) 937-9445 or Toll-free (Canada & US) +1 (888) 947-9445
AnaMaria said:
That was my thought. You were not married at the time of her application nor when she landed. There is no need to include her boyfriend in the applications, isn't there? Were you engaged to her that time?

Yes AnaMaria reading your post makes me more baffled, bf and gf do not need to be included. I am confused now, I thought they were married when she initially applied
 
R151NG5UN said:
Oh no! Now I understand what has happened. Regardless of the fact that you were not applying for PR or had anything to do with her application, 1 of the forms says that you must add all dependants, siblings, parents, grandparents and spouses and obtain medical clearances for any of those that you may wish to sponsor in future. If you fail to declare any of these people any future sponsorships will be closed off.

Now why that is the case I am not sure, I guess it closes off background checks on the fore-mentioned family members. This is going to be really complex and difficult for you. Maybe post on the top subject and Computergeek or 1 of the mods can help here. I have a feeling you may now need to consult with a very good immigration lawyer. I do know leaving people off any previous applications can impact severely any future applications.

oh no no no no..is that so?what should we do to my paper being forwarded to my visa office?regardless of being her ineligibilty?
 
besykobuset said:
oh no no no no..is that so?what should we do to my paper being forwarded to my visa office?regardless of being her ineligibilty?

I think I may have been wrong besykobuset. It depends on your relationship status at the time she applied for PR? If you were married or common law then what I said was right I believe but if you were only BF/GF then it appears the forms were filled out correctly. If I were you post in the spouse sponsorship at the top of the forum. There are others who know more than me. I am a little baffled by this situation if I am totally honest. I will try and find out more information but for now I must sleep, I will look in to this more tomorrow but I would post in the top topic.

Wishing you the best of luck :D
 
besykobuset said:
oh no no no no..is that so?what should we do to my paper being forwarded to my visa office?regardless of being her ineligibilty?

Sorry to hear about this. I really didn't know people had to declare their gf/bfs when applying for PR. Partner is another matter but dating?

I'm guessing that in IMM1344, first question you guys have checked "Proceed with the application for permanent residence" vs the first option, which is "withdraw your sponsorship application". Therefore, they are forwarding the file to the VO despite the sponsorship not being approved.
 
Hi besykobuset: I probably understood the reason CIC is considering. You probably mentioned that your relationship with your spouse started since 2007 which is even before her PR application as a dependent with her father/family. So CIC considered the factor that your relation (as a gf/bf) started actually before she even became PR. Therefore, your name should have been in her application, NO MATTER, she was dependent in her father's application. Although your relation was not defined before 2009 according to your culture, probably. Humm......I am learning new things every day in this forum. Personally, I don't agree with this notion of undefined relation that was considered in your case. It is dilemma of facts. Very SAD! I feel sorry for you. Wish you good luck though.
 
singaporeVO said:
Hi besykobuset: I probably understood the reason CIC is considering. You probably mentioned that your relationship with your spouse started since 2007 which is even before her PR application as a dependent with her father/family. So CIC considered the factor that your relation (as a gf/bf) started actually before she even became PR. Therefore, your name should have been in her application, NO MATTER, she was dependent in her father's application. Although your relation was not defined before 2009 according to your culture, probably. Humm......I am learning new things every day in this forum. Personally, I don't agree with this notion of undefined relation that was considered in your case. It is dilemma of facts. Very SAD! I feel sorry for you. Wish you good luck though.

oh my god..we are so confused..this is a really big WHY?what should we do? there is no need for my papers to be processed in my VO since she is not eligible to sponsor.it will be denied for sure..is there any way we can withdraw my papers because we chose to continue processing it regardless of ineligibility during the initial application.we waited this for 5 months :( :( :(
 
R151NG5UN said:
I think I may have been wrong besykobuset. It depends on your relationship status at the time she applied for PR? If you were married or common law then what I said was right I believe but if you were only BF/GF then it appears the forms were filled out correctly. If I were you post in the spouse sponsorship at the top of the forum. There are others who know more than me. I am a little baffled by this situation if I am totally honest. I will try and find out more information but for now I must sleep, I will look in to this more tomorrow but I would post in the top topic.

Wishing you the best of luck :D

thank you so much for your help :D i really appreciate it
 
besykobuset said:
oh my god..we are so confused..this is a really big WHY?what should we do? there is no need for my papers to be processed in my VO since she is not eligible to sponsor.it will be denied for sure..is there any way we can withdraw my papers because we chose to continue processing it regardless of ineligibility during the initial application.we waited this for 5 months :( :( :(


Hi besykobuset: PLEASE email CIC ASAP to withdraw the application. Then think about it to re-apply with the help of a lawyer. This is the best option now to withdraw the application in my personal opinion. However, I would encourage to discuss the issue with a good lawyer, please. Hope things will be on track soon. Good luck.
 
besykobuset said:
thank you so much for your help :D i really appreciate it
this is very strange I have read.
there was no need to mention about you in your wife's application since you were just BF/GF
I am so sorry..
call CIC to withdraw the application... and then hire a good immigration lawyer.these days even the stage 1 time is less and goodluck
 
singaporeVO said:
Hi besykobuset: PLEASE email CIC ASAP to withdraw the application. Then think about it to re-apply with the help of a lawyer. This is the best option now to withdraw the application in my personal opinion. However, I would encourage to discuss the issue with a good lawyer, please. Hope things will be on track soon. Good luck.

im looking for the email address or way to email CIC but cant find it.. can you help me how?
 
To withdraw the application :

CPCM-EXTCOM@cic.gc.ca
 
http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/immigrate/sponsor/relatives-apply-after.asp
 
singaporeVO said:
http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/immigrate/sponsor/relatives-apply-after.asp

thank you so much
 
besykobuset said:
march 2012 and our relationship started 2007

I am really sorry for u but the way i see things you probably mentioned in your application that your relationship start in 2007 hence CIC are assuming that if that was the case then your wife should have mentioned you when she was being sponsored as a dependent child. Like others have suggested withdraw the entire application and see a good lawyer asap. My friend got the same problem as yours when his wife was trying to sponsor him so good luck and take it easy cos i could put myself in ur shoes to feel the pain of such a long wait.
 
Besy - so sorry about this! I don't know what to say!