CWP/LMIA positive

[rxtve]

got a positive LMIA/CAQ (not duel intent) - applying for closed work permit. quebec.
1. how long does this process take on average?
2. I have seen people get their CWP refused with positive LMIA, how likely is this to happen? are there particular reasons for it?
3. Can i apply for a TRV on the basis of a submission of a CWP, with positive LMIA and CAQ in the application ?

 

[Naturgrl]

1. Are you in Canada or not? If in Canada what is your status?
2. Depends on your job experience, education and language skills. You are proving that no Canadian can do the job.
3. Are you in Canada or not?

 

[rxtve]

1. Are you in Canada or not? If in Canada what is your status?
2. Depends on your job experience, education and language skills. You are proving that no Canadian can do the job.
3. Are you in Canada or not?

1. in canada currently on pgwp. been working with this employer already on this status and applied to switch to closed work permit after pgwp expires
3. yes. in canada
2. we had a simplified process. does that affect anything?

 

[Naturgrl]

1. in canada currently on pgwp. been working with this employer already on this status and applied to switch to closed work permit after pgwp expires
3. yes. in canada
2. we had a simplified process. does that affect anything?

1. Current processing is over 200 days.
2. There is always a chance of refusal.
3. You can apply for a TRV on a PGWP.

 

[rxtve]

1. Current processing is over 200 days.
2. There is always a chance of refusal.
3. You can apply for a TRV on a PGWP.

3. pgwp expires in october so if i apply now will i get it beyond that date? i have a trv right now that expires at the same time as the pgwp. so I’m wondering about the visa to apply for if i want to travel after october and return to canada, provided I have approval for Cwp.

 

[forevermore76]

3. pgwp expires in october so if i apply now will i get it beyond that date? i have a trv right now that expires at the same time as the pgwp. so I’m wondering about the visa to apply for if i want to travel after october and return to canada, provided I have approval for Cwp.

You'll have to wait for an approved work permit before applying for TRV.

 

[canuck78]

3. pgwp expires in october so if i apply now will i get it beyond that date? i have a trv right now that expires at the same time as the pgwp. so I’m wondering about the visa to apply for if i want to travel after october and return to canada, provided I have approval for Cwp.

Realistically October travel may not be possible. Unless you have your new WP you would be on implied status so if you left Canada you could not return and work.

 

[Iva Sp]

Hello guys, I am new, and I would like to get information on how does LMIA actually work. Do I need to be already job given by LMIA holder, then apply for the PN program or to apply first, then wait for job offer? Could someone please explain to me, as I am confused, as I read some official articles by CIC and when it is about PNprogram many times it is mentioned that you have to be inside the country. I am overseas, I have no CA education, no CA work experience, and no relatives living in CA

 

[canuck78]

Hello guys, I am new, and I would like to get information on how does LMIA actually work. Do I need to be already job given by LMIA holder, then apply for the PN program or to apply first, then wait for job offer? Could someone please explain to me, as I am confused, as I read some official articles by CIC and when it is about PNprogram many times it is mentioned that you have to be inside the country. I am overseas, I have no CA education, no CA work experience, and no relatives living in CA

Getting PR without an education and work experience is almost impossible these days. You really need to do more research on the various pathways to secure PR or hire an immigration lawyer. A job offer with approved LMIA will no longer help you secure PR due to recent changes.

 

[YVR123]

Hello guys, I am new, and I would like to get information on how does LMIA actually work. Do I need to be already job given by LMIA holder, then apply for the PN program or to apply first, then wait for job offer? Could someone please explain to me, as I am confused, as I read some official articles by CIC and when it is about PNprogram many times it is mentioned that you have to be inside the country. I am overseas, I have no CA education, no CA work experience, and no relatives living in CA

high level about LMIA:
An employer post a job position and couldn't find a Canadian/PR that can do that job. And only you have the education and experience to fill that position.
So yes, most cases, employers are only willing to file for LMIA (it cost them $1000 to apply plus fee to lawyer if they hire a lawyer to handle this).
Once that LMIA is approved, you (or the person that can fill that position) can apply for a closed work permit for that employer. You need to again proof that your education and experience fits that position.

So then, you will be ONLY working for that employer if the closed work permit is approved.

As pointed out by another member, LMIA and a closed work permit alone will not help in terms of applying for PR.

 

[Talwindersingh]

Hi everyone

I have high wage new lmia from the same employer that I’m working from last 3 years on lmia based work permit . Currently i have experience as warehouse supervisor but the new lmia is under my name is for printing press supervisor. Employer ask for 1 to less then 7 month of experience required for new lmia application. Currently I’m performing 70% same duties. My question is there any red flag by switching the job (new lmia based work permit application) into different position? I check by myself I’m performing all supervisory duties but lag in technical duties that’s why I said 70% match. My consultant told me there will be no issue in this coz employer only ask for 1 to less then 7 month experience required which is considered as on-job training. In letter of explanation they did not mentioned about on job training thing

 

[Jasskaur102]

Hello everyone,
I am sharing my full situation to get advice from members who have experience with LMIA work permits and refusal under R183 or R200(1)(b). I previously lived in Canada for six years and always tried to follow all rules, so I want to make sure I correct everything properly in my new application.
My Timeline (Clear Summary)

• Arrived in Canada: August 2019 (international student)
• Completed 2-year ECE Diploma at Sheridan College
• PGWP applied: June 3, 2021
• PGWP approved: August 30, 2021 (valid to August 30, 2024)
• Worked as Retail Sales Supervisor (Petro-Canada): January 2022 – August 2024
• Employer applied for LMIA
• I applied for a work permit extension: August 29, 2024 (implied status)
• WP extension refusal: December 15, 2024 – I stopped working immediately
• Applied for restoration as a visitor: March 13, 2025
• Restoration refused: August 19, 2025
• I had already booked my flight on August 8, and left Canada on August 27
• I never overstayed and never worked after refusal

Refusal reasons

The officer refused my LMIA work permit under R200(1)(b) and wrote

• I did not comply with conditions under R183
• I was in Canada without status after my work permit expired
• My purpose of visit is not consistent with a temporary stay
• Officer is not satisfied that I will leave Canada at the end of my authorized stay

Why I Believe This Was a Misunderstanding

• I stopped working the same day my extension was refused
• I applied for restoration within the 90-day restoration period
• I left Canada voluntarily and on time
• I booked my return flight before the refusal decision (proof attached in my application)
• I have always maintained legal status from 2019 to 2025
• I have strong ties in India and never had any intention to stay illegally

Current Issue

My LMIA expires on January 18, and my lawyer is preparing a new work permit application with:

• full explanation letter
• proof of restoration timing
• flight booking email
• timeline summary
• proof of strong home ties that is some property, house, parents

My Questions to the Community

1. Has anyone had a similar refusal under R183 / R200(1)(b) and later got approved while applying from India?
2. Will applying close to the LMIA expiry (Jan 18) hurt my chances?
3. Does showing proof that I booked my flight before the refusal help strengthen the application?
4. Based on your experience, what are the realistic approval chances for a second attempt with proper explanations?
5. What else should I include to strengthen my new work permit application from India in this case?

Thank you