+1(514) 937-9445 or Toll-free (Canada & US) +1 (888) 947-9445
What is new here ?
What's new? It runs counter to the perception that one can make a land entry to Canada on non Commercial vehicle without PRC or PRTD...
 
Reading through that, it still seems you can make entry via private vehicle without a PR card. I don't think you've ever really been able to use commercial transportation without a PR card or PRTD.

Returning by private vehicle
There are other documents you can use to enter the country.

When you return to Canada, apply for a PR cardif you plan to travel outside Canada again.

Some examples of private vehicles include, but are not limited to: a car, truck, motorcycle, or recreational vehicle that you own, borrow, or rent, and that is not available for public use.
 
Yes, that is what I understood too. I don't anything mentioning that you cannot cross land border in a private vehicle without PRC or PRTD.
 
This doesn't seem to affect private vehicles. Besides, if a PR can make it to a POE (which is physically on Canadian soil) I don't think CBSA can deny them entry regardless of whether or not they have the proper documents.
 
At the risk of feeding the troll . . . this topic is more malarkey . . . this time playing off (distorting, exaggerating, abusing) the meaning and use of a word like "return."

Nonetheless, to be clear, a PR is statutorily entitled to enter Canada, no particular documentation necessary. Nothing new here. IRCC cannot change this. Only Parliament, with the affirmation of the Senate and Royal Assent, could change this.

See Section 27 IRPA http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/I-2.5/page-7.html#h-19

What documentation is required for a PR to board a flight headed to Canada (as in what is required to "return" to Canada on an airline) is a separate issue, governed by the statutes and regulations prescribing the obligations of commercial transportation providers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: scylla
Unless you enter by private vehicle. The details don't support your premise.......alternate ID is suitable for establishing proof of residence at a land POE. Rishi888 is correct. There is no change.

Returning by private vehicle
There are other documents you can use to enter the country.

http://www.cbsa.gc.ca/travel-voyage/td-dv-eng.html

Residents returning to Canada
Acceptable documents to denote identity and/or citizenship
You should carry a valid Canadian passport for all visits abroad, including visits to the United States (U.S.). A passport may be required by your airline or alternative transportation authority, as it is the only universally-accepted identification document, and it proves that you have a right to return to Canada.

Upon arrival at a Canadian port of entry, travellers must satisfy a CBSA border services officer (BSO) that they meet the requirements for entry into Canada. For Canadian citizens, permanent residents and Registered Indians under the Indian Act, this can be done through questioning and through verifying documentation such as a Canadian passport, a Canadian birth certificate, a permanent residence card, a citizenship card, or a Secure Certificate of Indian Status (SCIS) card.

If you do not have a passport, and are returning to Canada, the following documents can denote identity and/or citizenship:

  • NEXUS card, held by a Canadian citizen, when entering Canada by air (when coming from the U.S.), land, or marine modes
  • FAST card (Free and Secure Trade), issued to a Canadian citizen (when arriving by land or marine modes only)
  • Canadian Emergency Travel Document
  • Canadian Temporary Passport
  • Certificate of Canadian Citizenship (issued from 1954 to present)
  • Enhanced Driver's License issued by a Canadian province or territory
  • Enhanced Identification/Photo Card issued by a Canadian province or territory
Permanent residents of Canada who are members of the NEXUS or FAST programs must travel with a passport and proof of permanent residence, and may be asked to present these documents to the officer upon arrival at the border.

Other acceptable documents for establishing Canadian citizenship
The following documents may be used to establish Canadian citizenship. Upon presentation by travellers, the documents should be supported by other government issued photo identification:

  • Certificate of Canadian Citizenship (large form issued between January 1, 1947 to February 14, 1977)
  • Certificate of Retention (issued between January 1, 1947 and February 14, 1977)
  • Certificate of Naturalization (issued before January 1, 1947)
  • Registration of Birth Abroad Certificate (issued between January 1, 1947 and February 14, 1977 by Canadian citizenship authorities)
  • Provincial or Territorial Birth Certificate (individuals born in Canada)
Other acceptable documents to support identity
The following documents may be used to establish your identity.

  • CANPASS card (Air, Corporate Air, Private Air, Boats, Remote Area Border Crossing), held by a Canadian citizen
  • Commercial Driver Registration Program card, held by a Canadian citizen
  • Provincial and Territorial Driver's License
  • Employment or student card with photo and signature
  • Provincial Health Insurance Card
  • Provincial identity card
  • Canadian Forces Identification
  • Police Identification
  • Firearms Acquisition Certificate
  • Social Insurance Number Card
  • Credit Card
  • Vehicle Insurance Certificate
  • Vehicle Registration
 
Deny entry, may be not...

https://twitter.com/CitImmCanada/status/910489013928173568 ------->
"Even if you are from a visa-exempt country, CDN permanent residents need a PR Card or PRTD to return to Canada. http://ow.ly/28Ei30ePbPH "
That's irrelevant.

If you can make it to a Canadian border post - which, realistically, means a US land crossing, or a Canadian airport - and establish your identity, CBSA have no choice but to let you in. Even the COPR at that point is a nice-to-have rather than a necessity.

Separately from that, no commercial travel company - plane, ship, coach, train, will allow you to board something which intends to cross the border if you can't give them proof, or strong indication, that you'll be allowed in, and for that, a PR requires a PRC/PRTD.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rish888
Even if there is a technical IRCC requirement to have a PR card, as spousalsponsee said, if one can make it to a Canadian POE, regardless of how they get there or by what means of transport, CBSA is obliged to let them in.