Hi! I’m extremely sorry if I came on insensitive. My point was that I am reading how disturbed the OP is and this is literally life ruining for anybody but I’m also seeing that despite of trying to present all the evidence etc the only conclusion people are coming at is “consult an immigration lawyer” that specializes in dealing with this. I know this is a very harrowing experience for the OP and maybe the OP does not want to spend thousands of dollars on a lawyer. But my point wasn’t that they should not ask here, it was only that it’s actually sad seeing the said person running in circles and not getting a straightforward help (because people can only offer advices here). I would suggest the OP to approach a lawyer who has been in this field for more than 10 years. Because I kept an RCIC lawyer myself but believe me I knew more than him. He only got his license 2 years back and with the increasing number of students asking for help, anybody with a PR is becoming an RCIC or immigration lawyer. So please dread carefully before giving them more money after being at this huge loss.