FSW WORLDWIDE

[slavicgirl]

So i have done some research on this earlier as some one in my near family had the exact same issue. Their child was a canadian citizen but had a neuro-degenerative disease known as tay sachs. Their PR was denied, they asked them to leave the child in canada.

Leave the child? Serious?

 

[NavjotS123]

not just the mother's but the father's age can also be a contributing factor

Actually you may be right, but my research only concentrated on maternal age

 

[dxdroid]

So i have done some research on this earlier as some one in my near family had the exact same issue. Their child was a canadian citizen but had a neuro-degenerative disease known as tay sachs. Their PR was denied, they asked them to leave the child in canada.

Are you serious? That cannot be true.

 

[NavjotS123]

Leave the child? Serious?

or take it with them.

 

[NavjotS123]

Are you serious?

100%

 

[GandiBaat]

So i have done some research on this earlier as some one in my near family had the exact same issue. Their child was a canadian citizen but had a neuro-degenerative disease known as tay sachs. Their PR was denied, they asked them to leave the child in canada.

Weird! Thats not possible. First, it will be a HR&C case. Second, Canadian citizen is not even a part of the application, they remove them if you add them as dependent. Lastly, there is no medical done for Canadian Citizen.

In Canadian law, separating Child from parents is considered high sin in Human Rights laws. It wont stand one chance in court of law.

 

[dxdroid]

100%

That's ok obviously I mean they had an option and people have different situations.

 

[NavjotS123]

We applied in September. They did not ask for his medical at all.

that's good for you. The case i am referring to happened before 2018 when the ceiling was way lower

 

[NavjotS123]

Weird! Thats not possible. First, it will be a HR&C case. Second, Canadian citizen is not even a part of the application, they remove them if you add them as dependent. Lastly, there is no medical done for Canadian Citizen.

In Canadian law, separating Child from parents is considered high sin in Human Rights laws. It wont stand one chance in court of law.

Man i am not lying to you. I can get you an exact same news article give me some time please

 

[slavicgirl]

Weird! Thats not possible. First, it will be a HR&C case. Second, Canadian citizen is not even a part of the application, they remove them if you add them as dependent. Lastly, there is no medical done for Canadian Citizen.

In Canadian law, separating Child from parents is considered high sin in Human Rights laws. It wont stand one chance in court of law.

don't stress yourself over this. Neurodegenerative disease is a totally different thing, it can affect balance, movement, talking etc. Autism is very much different

 

[NavjotS123]

don't stress yourself over this. Neurodegenerative disease is a totally different thing, it can affect balance, movement, talking etc. Autism is very much different

You are right. Neurodegenerative disease is a death sentence to the child. Autism has spectrums. Some autisms are very mild and the social support will be under the 20k celing

 

[GandiBaat]

Man i am not lying to you. I can get you an exact same news article give me some time please

I am not saying that. I am just trying to figure out how will they take that information in when in entire application they do not have any part like that. Also,

https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/i-2.5/section-38.html

The medical inadmissibilty is defined in context of foreign national only.

• 38 (1) A foreign national is inadmissible on health grounds if their health condition
  • (a) is likely to be a danger to public health;
  • (b) is likely to be a danger to public safety; or
  • (c) might reasonably be expected to cause excessive demand on health or social services.

So at worst a foreign unaccompanying applicant / dependent be considered medically inadmissible... But a canadian citizen is not foreign national... so how will the law even apply.

don't stress yourself over this. Neurodegenerative disease is a totally different thing, it can affect balance, movement, talking etc. Autism is very much different

I am not stressed on it because in my application medical part is passes and at worst they can order a re-medical for us. My kid, whom I added to the application was removed from that with a mention in GCMS notes that he is canadian citizen so he cann't be an accompanying applicant.

 

[NavjotS123]

I am not saying that. I am just trying to figure out how will they take that information in when in entire application they do not have any part like that. Also,

https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/i-2.5/section-38.html

The medical inadmissibilty is defined in context of foreign national only.

• 38 (1) A foreign national is inadmissible on health grounds if their healthcondition
  • (a) is likely to be a danger to public health;
  • (b) is likely to be a danger to public safety; or
  • (c) might reasonably be expected to cause excessive demand on health or social services.

So at worst a foreign unaccompanying applicant / dependent be considered medically inadmissible... But a canadian citizen is not foreign national... so how will the law even apply.


I am not stressed on it because in my application medical part is passes and at worst they can order a re-medical for us. My kid, whom I added to the application was removed from that with a mention in GCMS notes that he is canadian citizen so he cann't be an accompanying applicant.

SO they assess the dependents. I know i sound ridiculous but this thing has happened, give me some time. I will get you a court case copy and news article both.

 

[GandiBaat]

SO they assess the dependents. I know i sound ridiculous but this thing has happened, give me some time. I will get you a court case copy and news article both.

Yes, any accompanying or non accompanying foreign dependents are a part of application.

But Canadian citizen dependents are not. They are removed from application and if you paid their fee it is refunded.

That being said, I will love to see the case.

 

[NavjotS123]

Yes, any accompanying or non accompanying foreign dependents are a part of application.

But Canadian citizen dependents are not. They are removed from application and if you paid their fee it is refunded.

That being said, I will love to see the case.

yep. I'll DM you okay? Actually i m outside i don't have computer access. But i am pretty certain of the case