+1(514) 937-9445 or Toll-free (Canada & US) +1 (888) 947-9445

Briar1990

Newbie
Apr 25, 2018
2
0
Hi folks. I wanted to clarify something. I have about 1 year out of 5 lived in Canada in the last 5 years. I was working in Canada as a PR and was asked to be transferred to US with assignment letter about 4 years ago (it was kind of move or lose your job situation). I am working in US since then, and looks like they are planning to send me back to Canada soon.

The thing is the entity I work here is the US branch of the global company, so I don't know if it counts as a Canadian Business, even if assignment is originated from Canadian office. If I apply for PTRD (PR card expired) and upload assignment letter does that work as means of meeting RO? I do not think company will provide specific letter that IRCC describes on their website.

Or is it better to enter via land border and present the assignment letter there.
 
Hi folks. I wanted to clarify something. I have about 1 year out of 5 lived in Canada in the last 5 years. I was working in Canada as a PR and was asked to be transferred to US with assignment letter about 4 years ago (it was kind of move or lose your job situation). I am working in US since then, and looks like they are planning to send me back to Canada soon.

The thing is the entity I work here is the US branch of the global company, so I don't know if it counts as a Canadian Business, even if assignment is originated from Canadian office. If I apply for PTRD (PR card expired) and upload assignment letter does that work as means of meeting RO? I do not think company will provide specific letter that IRCC describes on their website.

Or is it better to enter via land border and present the assignment letter there.
It doesn't count towards RO.
 
Hi folks. I wanted to clarify something. I have about 1 year out of 5 lived in Canada in the last 5 years. I was working in Canada as a PR and was asked to be transferred to US with assignment letter about 4 years ago (it was kind of move or lose your job situation). I am working in US since then, and looks like they are planning to send me back to Canada soon.

The thing is the entity I work here is the US branch of the global company, so I don't know if it counts as a Canadian Business, even if assignment is originated from Canadian office. If I apply for PTRD (PR card expired) and upload assignment letter does that work as means of meeting RO? I do not think company will provide specific letter that IRCC describes on their website.

Or is it better to enter via land border and present the assignment letter there.

It is nearly impossible to quantify the odds a PR in your situation will be able to save their PR status. Frankly, based on what you have shared, the odds do not look good, but the actual odds vary considerably and depend on the particular details in your specific circumstances.

Advantage of land border return:

The main advantage of returning to Canada via a land border Port-of-Entry (PoE), rather than applying for a PR Travel Document, is there is some chance border officials waive you through without conducting an assessment/examination of your compliance with the PR Residency Obligation. That would effectively mean you are allowed to keep your PR status. In contrast, a PR TD application will for sure involve an assessment of RO compliance.

This does not mean the odds are good you will be waived through, but there is some chance of that. If that is how it goes, if you are waived through, you could then stay here, live and work here, and in two years make an application for a new PR card. This would not be problem free, but for many it is workable.

Advantage of PR TD application:

The main advantage of making the application for a PR Travel Document is the outcome of that would be more definitive. You would know, mostly know, how things will go.

If the PR TD is issued, you could then make the move to Canada knowing you can come here to stay, to live and work. And you could probably proceed to safely (relatively safely) make an application to get a new PR card farily soon after you settle and are working here.

A Canadian immigration lawyer can make that application on your behalf. Probably expensive, but a Canadian lawyer could put together the best case for (1) claiming working-abroad-RO-credit (to the extent there is such a case to be made), and alternatively (2) presenting your situation in the best light for H&C relief.


Preparation for land border return:

If you want to pursue returning to Canada to live and work here, and you choose to return via a land border PoE, you should be prepared for a RO examination at the border (hope to be waived through, but be prepared for a RO examination and inadmissibility proceedings). If you have access to a Canadian immigration lawyer before you make the move, it could be very helpful to obtain an in-depth evaluation of your case, and get advice from the lawyer about how to best present your case to an immigration officer examining your RO compliance. Otherwise, probably the best approach is to be prepared to honestly tell your story at the border. That would include presenting your best case for claiming the working-abroad-RO-credit, to the extent you can honestly make that case. This, by the way, can also be part of your explanation for why you have been outside Canada so long, part of the case to be made for H&C relief.

If you elect to take this approach, there is no need for you to judge whether you will actually qualify for and be given working-abroad-RO-credit. Even though, based on what you have so far shared, it is likely that @Naturgrl is correct that you will not get RO credit for this time, you do not share enough information for anyone here to say so that definitively. Rather, if you are making the effort to save your PR status, it should be worth claiming the credit (be sure to play it straight, only present truthful information), and even if an officer does not allow this credit, this information helps explain why you have not been in Canada and could be a significant factor in determining if you are allowed to keep PR status (given H&C relief) despite the RO breach.

Here too, this is not to say the odds are good you will be given H&C relief and allowed to keep status. But this approach should give you the better odds (subject to learning a better approach from a lawyer who has been paid to evaluate your case in detail).

Some forum participants might point out that going and staying outside Canada for work is a personal choice, and because of that it will not be given positive H&C weight. That's not how the assessment of H&C factors works. What influence the choice to leave Canada to work elsewhere has will vary depending on the rest of the situation. Which brings this back to comparing a land border entry with a PR TD application.

More PR TD versus land border entry observations:

If you make a PR TD application, a visa officer will first determine whether you qualify for the working-abroad-RO-credit, and that will be based on a full evaluation of the information and documentation submitted, but will likely also be based on additional sources of information. Unless you submit documentation that shows (1) the employer qualifies as a Canadian business and (2) you were temporarily assigned to the work, the odds (as has been noted) are you will not be allowed this credit. PR TD denied.

In contrast, I doubt anyone here can definitively say how a border officer will respond if, in being asked about your RO, you explain that your employer assigned you to a position in the U.S. and you are finally getting to return to Canada where you will continue to work for the same employer. That might be enough to get a waive through, perhaps a waive through with advice from the officer (which may seem like an instruction) to make an application for a new PR card soon. If you are waived through, you do not need to make a PR card application anytime soon . . . even if the border officer made it sound like you do . . . but, rather, you can live and work here, stay here and wait until you have stayed long enough to apply for a new PR card (appears that would take two years for you).

The officer may choose to probe the circumstances of your work in the U.S. and the respective assignments or transfers. Be sure to be totally honest. Avoid being vague or evasive. If the officer concludes you are in breach of the RO (because you do not qualify for working-abroad-RO-credit), and thus does not waive you through but, rather, prepares a 44(1) Report (for inadmissibility due to a RO breach), you can still make the same claim for working-abroad-RO-credit to the officer who reviews that Report, and do so along with explaining your story to the reviewing officer, including why you think you should be allowed to keep your PR status, allowed to pursue a permanent life in Canada.

In practice how that goes procedurally can vary significantly. This can get complicated. One variation we have seen in anecdotal reporting lately is the same officer who conducts the RO compliance examination might proceed to discuss the potential H&C side of things before preparing a 44(1) Report, and decide to not prepare the Report. That would be the equivalent of being waived through (and if Canadian PR is important for you, cause for celebration).

Another variation in the procedure after a Report is prepared is to allow the PR to proceed into Canada, in effect postponing review of the Report by another officer to later. Historically the post-poned follow-up with the reviewing officer (technically acting in the role of a Minister's Delegate and typically done telephonically) usually took place within days to a couple months. But we have seen anecdotal reporting from some PRs who have been suspended in this stage of inadmissibility proceedings for many months or even longer than a year.

The latter brings up another slight advantage to the land border approach. Even if the reviewing officer denies H&C relief, and thus issues a Removal/Departure Order, the PR is allowed to enter Canada and is still a PR, still able to live and work in Canada, for so long as they have a right of appeal. So the PR can appeal and in the meantime proceed to live and work in Canada, and demonstrate by their actions they have both the intent and the means to settle and stay here permanently, which could be a significantly positive H&C factor when the IAD actually hears and decides the appeal. This is only a slight advantage since after a PR TD has been denied, technically a PR can appeal, and in the meantime still come to Canada, and similarly stay and work pending the outcome of the appeal.

CAVEAT/caution:

It is very difficult to say whether the odds of saving your PR status are good enough for you to make the effort. That is a very personal decision and it depends on how important PR is to you and it depends on many particular factors which will influence the odds, what an immigration officer will decide. Again, what you have shared here suggests the odds are not good. But the details matter. Which details and how they can influence things is a big subject in itself. Ask if you want more information about that.
 
Hi folks. I wanted to clarify something. I have about 1 year out of 5 lived in Canada in the last 5 years. I was working in Canada as a PR and was asked to be transferred to US with assignment letter about 4 years ago (it was kind of move or lose your job situation). I am working in US since then, and looks like they are planning to send me back to Canada soon.

The thing is the entity I work here is the US branch of the global company, so I don't know if it counts as a Canadian Business, even if assignment is originated from Canadian office. If I apply for PTRD (PR card expired) and upload assignment letter does that work as means of meeting RO? I do not think company will provide specific letter that IRCC describes on their website.

Or is it better to enter via land border and present the assignment letter there.
Instead of a long response

No
 
If that is how it goes, if you are waived through, you could then stay here, live and work here, and in two years make an application for a new PR card. This would not be problem free, but for many it is workable.
A caveat (one that I think could be VERY important, even crucial or determinative in this particular case) if the PR is waved through at the border (note, not a formal 'waiver', nothing in a strict sense is being 'waived' in the sense of formal or meaningful relief from the residency obligation or other aspects - they've just chosen not to do the full 44(1) procedure or take more formal steps ... this one single time. Past performance is no guarantee of, etc - future interactions may not go so well.).

Anyway, the point: for an individual let into Canada to live and work here for two years, and then to make an application for a new PR card - the difficulty with this scenario is that, repeat, the risk is afterwards low if the PR remains in Canada (and avoids further interaction with IRCC). But that low-risk 'base case' does not hold if the individual travels outside of Canada, esp if the travel is frequent, because every interaction at the port of entry bears the risk of having the (non)compliance being revisited every single time. And in any case, it's probable that the examining officer at the port of entry (either the first time or any subsequent time) warns about the RO compliance and makes a note to file.

For a PR working for a US company in Canada (even a local subsidiary), the expectation of the employer might well be that the employee can and will travel to the US, possibly on a more or less regular basis. Possibly frequently. So there's that risk of a subsequent examination resulting in the consequences outlined above. Which may get quite complicated, and possibly not be surmountable.

And the employer may not be 'on board' with all of that, and may not be at all amenable to exempting the employee from 'work requirements' to visit the US (or other countries). Not to mention that the PR card presumably expires in about one year, meaning the PR can't travel easily by air back to Canada until the PR card is renewed - leading the PR back to the same problems as above.

So @Briar1990 - if that particular employment is important to you, you have some hard choices to make. You may want/need to discuss with your employer. And/or a lawyer (on the immigration aspect, leaving aside the employment aspects).

Given that your employer is 'transferring' you back to Canada, they may have some expectation/belief that since you are a Canadian PR, that you can return to Canada and work 'as usual' - including travelling to USA or elsewhere as part of your employment. They may not be on board with a situation where your travel to USA is restricted, and they may not understand (or appreciate) the potential risks for your PR status.

I could be off base on that aspect (what the employer expects), but something to consider and look into.