Anyone with reasonable mindset would not expect people from Ukraine or other war torn country to return home as their countries would need years to rebuild physical infrastructure and functional economy. Healthcare, education, sense of safety and normalcy actually takes much longer time to restore. It is not only impractical, but also deeply disruptive to expect them to go back when the situation in their home countries is still uncertain or only marginally improved. Families from those countries have established new life in Canada and have integrated with the society, and have Canadian children whose best interests are to remain in Canada. I am not sure how you come to the idea that it is difficult to be accepted as Syrian refugee in Canada. IRB acceptance of refugee claims from Syria is still quite high. Despite major civil war has ended and Assad regime collapsed, Syria is still affected by clashes between various militia groups and there is no functional army or strong police force in Syria. There is no centralized universal government that would guarantee safey of everyone in Syria, and there are regions not controlled by the government. There are still credible claims related to safety, ongoing violence and lack of state protection and I think these are valid claims that will be accepted.This was never the plan. The plan was originally for only a work permit with no support and that was one of the justification for the no cap on applications. Once people arrived it became clear that many would not be able to work, many couldn’t support themselves especially initially, etc. and would then need access to public healthcare, financial support, etc. Where is your proof that there was always going to be a PR pathway and CUAET was the initial step? The H&C PR pathway was announced 1.5 yrs after CUAET and is limited to those with a family member who is a Canadian citizen or PR so not all Ukrainians in Canada. That essentially rules out your argument that CUAET was always meant as a transition to PR program. The hope was that there would be peace in Ukraine much faster and at least some people would be able to return. Nobody predicted that this war last as long as it has. It is now more difficult to get asylum from Syria so yes there is some expectation that some people will return to Ukraine. People’s old lives and home regions have been impacted very differently depending on where you are from in Ukraine. Ukraine will also need people to rebuild their country. Until there is peace and depending on what peace looks like it is impossible to know what impacts it will have impact on Ukrainians longterm immigration prospects in Canada. Immigration is often not black or white.
Last edited: