+1(514) 937-9445 or Toll-free (Canada & US) +1 (888) 947-9445

Responding to a Minister’s Appeal

roycanada

Star Member
Dec 1, 2017
172
59
Hi,

My claim was accepted (Protected Person) but got Notice of Appeal from Minister
Now I have to response to Minister appeal
is there Anyone in same position now, Please share your experience

Roy
 

visatest

Hero Member
May 24, 2016
485
91
London Ontario Canada
Hi,

We will reply to Minister Appeal.

How about you did you reply, what is waiting Time?

Roy
The story is as follows from the Immigration and Refugee Board Web Page:

"When the Minister appeals to the Refugee Appeal Division, the Minister is essentially having a positive refugee determination reviewed. The Minister must show that there were mistakes in the original refugee determination. These mistakes can be about the law, the facts, or both. The RAD will decide whether to confirm or change the Refugee Protection Division (RPD) decision. It may also decide to send the case back to the Refugee Protection Decision for re-determination while giving the directions to the RPD that it considers appropriate.

If you were granted refugee protection by the RPD and the Minister is appealing that decision, you have the right to respond to the appeal and to file documents. If you decide not to respond, the RAD will decide the Minister's appeal on the basis of the Minister's documents and the RPD record.

In a Minister's appeal, the Minister is called "the appellant" and you are called "the respondent.""

ref. https://irb-cisr.gc.ca/en/filing-refugee-appeal/Pages/minister1.aspx
 

Robrob

Star Member
Sep 2, 2019
56
18
Hi,

My claim was accepted (Protected Person) but got Notice of Appeal from Minister
Now I have to response to Minister appeal
is there Anyone in same position now, Please share your experience

Roy
Hi roy,

I am very thankful if you can share in brief that when you get positive desion and when minister send the paper other then notice of appeal means total time in between or any one has same position pls
Thx
 
Last edited:

roycanada

Star Member
Dec 1, 2017
172
59
Hi roy,

I am very thankful if you can share in brief that when you get positive desion and when minister send the paper other then notice of appeal means total time in between or any one has same position pls
Thx
HI,

CLAIM ACCPTED 20 APR 2019
NOD Received after 2 wks
Minister Appeal notice received after 4 wks
Minister papers received after 2 wks
repled after 1 wk
 

sahil100

Newbie
Apr 24, 2021
4
1
Hi,

My claim was accepted (Protected Person) but got Notice of Appeal from Minister
Now I have to response to Minister appeal
is there Anyone in same position now, Please share your experience

Roy
Plz tell if minister appeal got accepted or rejected i am in the same situation?
 

Whiskey2020

Hero Member
Apr 8, 2020
361
76
Hi,

My claim was accepted (Protected Person) but got Notice of Appeal from Minister
Now I have to response to Minister appeal
is there Anyone in same position now, Please share your experience

Roy
That happens to me back in 2019 I will advice you to get a lawyer to appeal for you because that's what I did during my appeal, And after one year I won my appeal please don't take this as nothing because if you don't act fast you may loss your protection. It will cost you money but you will be happy in long run.