.
However, after I applied, I left Canada. At that time, I met the 730-day requirement. So, with this resubmission, if my date is not locked at 24 September, I am not in compliance. I uploaded a clear version and resubmitted immediately. I can hope for the renewal sometime in late Dec or early Jan? If they take 24 Sept as the application date and count back the days.
Reminder: the Residency Obligation is ongoing and unrelated to the validity of the PR card. Thus, even if you have a brand new PR card, that will have no bearing on calculating your compliance with the Residency Obligation going forward.
Thus, even if the application you submitted had resulted in mailing you a new PR card, if you have been outside Canada for 1095 or more days within the previous five years, you are still in breach of the RO and at risk of inadmissibility proceedings when you next arrive at a Port-of-Entry seeking entry into Canada. Having a brand new PR card probably reduces the risk of PoE officials initiating inadmissibility proceedings (mostly because the new PR card might be enough for a border official to waive you through without looking at your case closely, without reviewing your travel history and RO compliance)
but, again, if you have been outside Canada for 1095 or more days within the last five years as of the date you next arrive here, you are still in breach of the RO and at risk of losing your PR status.
How much risk there is of encountering inadmissibility proceedings leading to the loss of PR status is very, very difficult to quantify even in very clear factual circumstances. But of course the longer you remain outside Canada before you return here to stay, the bigger the risk.
That is to say a new PR card does not entirely solve your RO breach issues.
Question is whether you can solve your RO breach issues going forward. Again, the sooner you get back to Canada, the better your odds are of saving your PR status.
Status of September PR card application and related observations:
If you resubmit a complete application within 90 days of the date the September application was signed/dated, it is possible that IRCC could approve that application, issue a new PR card, and mail it to your residential address in Canada. If you are still getting mail at that address, that's possible. And if there is someone to collect your mail who can, in turn, forward the PR card to you, that's probably the best case scenario for you.
You would still be in breach of the RO, however, so still at some risk when you return here. As previously noted, when you present a nearly new PR card at the PoE there is some chance that border officials do not look closely at you and your history, and waive you through. If that happens you are good to stay, and if you stay long enough to have spent 730 days in Canada within the previous five years, that will cure the RO breach.
There is a lot of "
if" in that scenario.
Locked-in date for RO compliance calculation:
As long as you resubmit a
complete application within 90 days of the date the September application was signed/dated, your RO compliance calculation is locked in for purposes of being eligible for a new PR card. (Only for that purpose.)
But, frankly, "
so what?" That will be of little consolation if IRCC nonetheless refers the application for complex screening that, in turn, leads to preparation of a 44(1) Report for inadmissibility due to your subsequent and current breach of the RO.
If you are still outside Canada when the application is accepted for processing, a referral for complex processing seems likely, at least likely if not for-sure. This would be because the application is first screened by computers employing automated processing, which includes AI components and machine analysis of relevant databases. I am not certain, but this probably involves some machine analysis that includes the PR's CBSA travel history. For a PR whose CBSA travel history reveals they have left Canada in the meantime (since date application was made), let alone if it reveals there is a RO breach, that will likely trigger complex processing.
And in that process, the application is probably flagged with a notation the PR has exited Canada since the date of the application. Things tend to get complicated in that event. How IRCC actually handles the particular PR and their PR card application can vary considerably, but IRCC commonly suspends further processing the application until the PR has returned to Canada. Another way IRCC sometimes responds in these scenarios is to require an in-person PR card pick-up, at which the question is whether IRCC issues a five year card, when the PR appears in person, or issues a one-year card while IRCC commences the 44(1) Report for inadmissibility procedure.
Other Issues Lurking In The Wings . . .
The circumstances you describe suggest there could be various issues lurking in your situation. But how serious any of that is will depend on many aspects of your case. How long you have now been outside Canada, and how much longer you remain outside Canada, are probably the two biggest factors which can influence how this goes. But your overall immigration history, the extent of your ongoing ties in Canada, the extent of your ties to residency or work outside Canada, are among other factors which can influence how this goes.
Your 730 obligation is not in question. Do not over think!. They have checked every other aspect of the application and have "RETURNED" due to a faded copy and nothing else. You will provide them the copy and you will have your PR by the end of the year (if they pace up) or early next year (if they continued with this pace).
Sorry, but . . . any time a PR is engaged in a PR card application (among other transactions with IRCC), compliance with the RO is in question.
Additionally, if an application is returned because it is not complete, it will be screened for completeness again when it is resubmitted. Moreover, a returned application has not been processed, so it is not true that IRCC has "
checked every other aspect of the application." On the contrary, when resubmitted every aspect of the application will be checked.
Given the circumstances of the OP's case, IRCC's processing timeline for most PR card applications offers very little, if any promise for when the OP's application will be processed, or even that the OP will be issued a new PR card.
Meanwhile, at the risk of playing language police, in regards to saying to the OP that "
you will have your PR by the end of the year (if they pace up) or early next year (if they continued with this pace)," the OP already has their "
PR" status. I am guessing you meant they would have a new PR card, not PR status. Thing is, depending on the entirety of the OP's situation, the question is whether or not the OP is facing the loss of PR by the end of the year or early in the next year. (No where near enough information about the OP's situation to venture any odds of this, but the longer the OP remains outside Canada the bigger the risk.)
I bring up the latter because the failure to distinguish PR status versus the PR card is a common mistake many make, failing to recognize that a new PR card does not restart the PR RO clock. And for many that is a crucial distinction.