Rejection

[Ironclad]

What is level of establishment ? :

it means how well your family is established in your home country or how well financially and socially your family is doing. Your father, mother, brothers and sisters. Your family businesses, property agricultural lands, your source of income etc.
If your all family members(siblings and parents) are in your home country and are doing well(good jobs, married had children etc) it shows strong establishment levels.
For instance if you have business or job which is high demanding in your home country.

Now apply this rule to every aspect in your case.

Even if one is well established but fails to demonstrate it properly, it will become irrelevant as the VO won't be satisfied.

@prachi167

 

[rower]

@Ironclad

What do you make of this statement from the VO: "The applicant's plan of studies seems to be vague and poorly documented. The applicant doesn't seem to be sufficiently well established that the proposed studies would be a reasonable expense."

 

[Ironclad]

@Ironclad

What do you make of this statement from the VO: "The applicant's plan of studies seems to be vague and poorly documented. The applicant doesn't seem to be sufficiently well established that the proposed studies would be a reasonable expense."

"doesn't seem to be sufficiently well established"
I agree with your reasoning that the applicant got refused because of vague study documentation but it's also due to lack of home ties. Saying vague study documentation alone is not rational, you are ignoring another full reason right before you.

 

[rower]

"sufficiently well established "
I agree your reasoning that the applicant got refused because of vague study documentation but it's also due to lack of home ties. Saying vague study documentation alone is not rational, you are ignoring another full reason right before you.

Thanks for clarifying that.

I was looking for a solution, hence suggested a rewrite of the SOP. The applicant seems to have some property in his/her name, parents have been employed for over 30 years, etc. however no bank statement or any job experience in his/her own name. So, what more can we advise this applicant? Any ideas, anyone?

I do not wish anyone to be rejected, not without sufficient reason. Looks like here the VO was a little hasty, don't you think?

 

[Ironclad]

Thanks for clarifying that.

I was looking for a solution, hence suggested a rewrite of the SOP. The applicant seems to have some property in his/her name, parents have been employed for over 30 years, etc. however no bank statement or any job experience in his/her own name. So, what more can we advise this applicant? Any ideas, anyone?

I do not wish anyone to be rejected, not without sufficient reason. Looks like here the VO was a little hasty, don't you think?

Of course but we can't blame the system, Even if one is well established but fails to demonstrate it properly, it will become irrelevant as the VO won't be satisfied.

Ties cannot be manipulated however it can slightly boosted i.e Significantly old bank statements, internships/apprenticeship, travel history to the five eyes etc.

 

[Ironclad]

My brother is on work permit. He resides in a foreign country with my parents.

Apply from home country to boost ties.

 

[DesiPikachu]

Apply from home country to boost ties.

I'll never understand why Canada is the only western country to have this weird policy of usually rejecting applicants applying from outside their homeland. Meanwhile other countries' VO's actually view this as a positive since you've essentially demonstrated that you've lived long-term in another country without violating its immigration laws.

 

[Ironclad]

I'll never understand why Canada is the only western country to have this weird policy of usually rejecting applicants applying from outside their homeland. Meanwhile other countries' VO's actually view this as a positive since you've essentially demonstrated that you've lived long-term in another country without violating its immigration laws.

It's a medieval middle age tactic used in the days of monarchy, no other country stresses so much on ties than Canada, that's why they are number one.

 

[shikshashrestha]

Is there anyone whose study permit got approval while applying from another country (not country of nationality)?