+1(514) 937-9445 or Toll-free (Canada & US) +1 (888) 947-9445

amam2024

Full Member
Sep 12, 2025
36
12
Hi, when I called the IRB inquiring about my case the officer said they're waiting for a judge to look at my case.. what does that usually mean? Like to determine whether it is a file review/less complex case or a full hearing would be required and send me a notice to appear? Or just to determine hearing date immediately? what would they mean at this stage?

Thanks
 
Hi, when I called the IRB inquiring about my case the officer said they're waiting for a judge to look at my case.. what does that usually mean? Like to determine whether it is a file review/less complex case or a full hearing would be required and send me a notice to appear? Or just to determine hearing date immediately? what would they mean at this stage?

Thanks

A “judge” is not needed to determine whether your case qualifies as less complex and whether you need a short or full hearing. There is a huge backlog of cases so it can now take 2-3+ years to have a hearing and the wait times will continue to increase.
 
Hi, when I called the IRB inquiring about my case the officer said they're waiting for a judge to look at my case.. what does that usually mean? Like to determine whether it is a file review/less complex case or a full hearing would be required and send me a notice to appear? Or just to determine hearing date immediately? what would they mean at this stage?

Thanks
Is your background check was complete from cbsa?
 
A “judge” is not needed to determine whether your case qualifies as less complex and whether you need a short or full hearing. There is a huge backlog of cases so it can now take 2-3+ years to have a hearing and the wait times will continue to increase.
I don’t know why some people on here are so eager to give discouraging feedback. Processing timelines for people applying today is 17 months. 17 months as of today is the maximum wait time. I don’t know where you are getting your information from.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lukas Olupot
I don’t know why some people on here are so eager to give discouraging feedback. Processing timelines for people applying today is 17 months. 17 months as of today is the maximum wait time. I don’t know where you are getting your information from.
You’re giving wrong information. 17 month is for those who applied for PR. This person is yet to do his hearing!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gusmcr
A “judge” is not needed to determine whether your case qualifies as less complex and whether you need a short or full hearing. There is a huge backlog of cases so it can now take 2-3+ years to have a hearing and the wait times will continue to increase.
A “judge” is not needed to determine whether your case qualifies as less complex and whether you need a short or full hearing. There is a huge backlog of cases so it can now take 2-3+ years to have a hearing and the wait times will continue to increase.
Ok then my question is still on, what would that mean? Why did they mention a judge at this point?
 
Ok then my question is still on, what would that mean? Why did they mention a judge at this point?
A judge is simply an IRB staff. They look at your claim, check, review and note down the loopholes if any. Then give you a date. I wish you all the best in your hearing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: trymebeyonce2020
I don’t know why some people on here are so eager to give discouraging feedback. Processing timelines for people applying today is 17 months. 17 months as of today is the maximum wait time. I don’t know where you are getting your information from.

As already pointed out asylum claimants are very frequently waiting 2-3 years at the moment for a hearing date and given the backlog this will only continue to increase unless there is some sort of significant reform. It is just basic math. I would want to know a realistic time period so I can make decisions about my life.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mancini
Hi, when I called the IRB inquiring about my case the officer said they're waiting for a judge to look at my case.. what does that usually mean? Like to determine whether it is a file review/less complex case or a full hearing would be required and send me a notice to appear? Or just to determine hearing date immediately? what would they mean at this stage?

Thanks
At the IRB, “judge” usually means a Board Member"
Suitable for file review (paper decision)?
Or does this require a full hearing?
 
At the IRB, “judge” usually means a Board Member"
Suitable for file review (paper decision)?
Or does this require a full hearing?
Thanks for answering!
Also is it ok for someone to submit a file review request form a year after the case was submitted as things has emerged?
 
Thanks for answering!
Also is it ok for someone to submit a file review request form a year after the case was submitted as things has emerged?
As far as I know is acceptable depends on what type of request you’re making?
Thanks for answering!
Also is it ok for someone to submit a file review request form a year after the case was submitted as things has emerged?
What kind of “file review request” are we talking about?
Are you requesting IRB to decide your case by paper (instead of a hearing)? The judge (board members) decides whether your case is suitable for file review.
 
Thanks for answering!
Also is it ok for someone to submit a file review request form a year after the case was submitted as things has emerged?

Dear @amam2024

Yes! You can definitely submit a request to IRB for your refugee application to be considered and processed under the File Review Process (Less Complex) without a hearing. This is officially published on IRB's website. This is a link from IRB's website about this process:

https://www.irb-cisr.gc.ca/en/forms/Pages/request-file-review-processing.aspx

There is a form that should be filled, and there are certain parameters/requirements that should be met for the request to be entertained: Mainly that your identity is confirmed (by passport, ID, etc.), that you, the claimant, believe that your claim is straightforward and not of a complex nature (no criminal background, etc.); you have satisfactory evidence, you come from a country with high approval rating, etc...

If you meet all these requirements, you can fill the form and submit your evidence to IRB. Sometimes, IRB will send an acknowledgement of receipt of the submission. I read somewhere that IRB may accept the request for file review submitted by the claimant provided that the front-end security screening is complete. If FESS is not complete, IRB will advise accordingly, that they cannot process the claim under the file review process due to incomplete FESS.

Therefore, the best course of action will be to ensure first that your FESS is complete. If so, you can fill the form, attach your evidence and submit everything to IRB.

It is ultimately up to IRB to approve this request.

Generally speaking, IRB may initially identify a claim as that it would be possible to be processed under the File Review Process. Upon reviewing all the submission, IRB may indeed be fully satisfied and will accept the claim and send the NOD without a hearing. However, having reviewed the submission, IRB may decide later that there are 1 or 2 specific points that should be investigated further with the claimant and accordingly will request a short hearing (that could last for up to a maximum of 1 hour). IRB could end up requesting a full hearing if the member believes that there are several issues that warrant further investigation..

One more fact: Even if IRB identifies a claim as falling under the File Review Process (Less Complex), this does not automatically warrant that the claim will be processed within 5-6 months. It still can take a long time, a very long time, to process the claim and send the NOD. With the huge backlog (300,000 claims), it may still take +20 months or even more to process the Less Complex cases....


Good Luck!
 
Last edited: