+1(514) 937-9445 or Toll-free (Canada & US) +1 (888) 947-9445

Gabbyhouse

Newbie
May 12, 2026
2
0
Hi All,

By way of background, I became a Canadian permanent resident in 2004, when I was approximately 13 years old. My family left Canada around a year later, when I was still a minor, and I have not returned to Canada since. I understand that this means I clearly do not meet the standard 730-day residency obligation.
However, I have recently been advised that my Canadian PR status has not been formally revoked and that I may still legally be a permanent resident unless and until an official decision is made removing that status.
I am now considering returning permanently to Canada. My intention would be to enter Canada by land from the United States, likely from Seattle, and present myself as a returning Canadian permanent resident. I would be travelling either alone first or with my family, depending on legal advice.
My family circumstances are as follows:
I have a long-term partner/wife, and we intend to be legally married before leaving the UK. We have children together, and she also has a 17-year-old son. I understand that, if we are legally married, her son may potentially be treated as my spouse’s dependent child for Canadian immigration purposes, provided he remains under 22 and is not married or in a common-law relationship. I would like advice on this point as well.
I am currently based in the UK and have a senior professional role as a Director in the property/real estate sector, earning a six-figure income. I am also in the process of selling my UK property, which may release approximately £200,000 in equity. I would therefore expect to have substantial settlement funds available, potentially CAD $300,000+ immediately accessible, with further funds available if required.
I would be seeking to relocate permanently, work in Canada, establish housing, enrol the children in school, integrate into the community, and build a long-term life there.
The key issue is that I am very concerned about being reported at the border for breach of the residency obligation. I would like advice on the likely process if this happens, including whether I would be allowed to enter Canada as a PR, whether a removal order could be issued, whether I would have a right of appeal to the Immigration Appeal Division, and how strong or weak my H&C case would realistically be.

I appreciate this is a long read, I look forward to hearing from you.
 
I don't have any experience or knowledge with this topic, but just commenting to share something i feel like i saw being discussed on the forum a while ago. Maybe you'll be able to find older posts by searching with certain keywords.

What i've read/heard is :
  • I believe you can only try and re-instate your Canadian PR if you move back/request to move back to Canada, immediately or very soon after turning 18.
  • It was something along the lines of : if you wait till later in life as in your case, it shows you were comfortable where you're at, so it probably won't work out from a H&C standpoint and you might just have to apply for a fresh PR/work permit at this stage.
But again, i would wait for some of the more knowledgeable folks on this topic here to reply, for more concrete answers.


Then the whole, 1. entering by land border vs airport (PRTD needed or not) & the subsequent 2. bringing along your family part (wife & kids) all come after you figure out the above first step.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gabbyhouse
Hi All,

By way of background, I became a Canadian permanent resident in 2004, when I was approximately 13 years old. My family left Canada around a year later, when I was still a minor, and I have not returned to Canada since. I understand that this means I clearly do not meet the standard 730-day residency obligation.
However, I have recently been advised that my Canadian PR status has not been formally revoked and that I may still legally be a permanent resident unless and until an official decision is made removing that status.
I am now considering returning permanently to Canada. My intention would be to enter Canada by land from the United States, likely from Seattle, and present myself as a returning Canadian permanent resident. I would be travelling either alone first or with my family, depending on legal advice.
My family circumstances are as follows:
I have a long-term partner/wife, and we intend to be legally married before leaving the UK. We have children together, and she also has a 17-year-old son. I understand that, if we are legally married, her son may potentially be treated as my spouse’s dependent child for Canadian immigration purposes, provided he remains under 22 and is not married or in a common-law relationship. I would like advice on this point as well.
I am currently based in the UK and have a senior professional role as a Director in the property/real estate sector, earning a six-figure income. I am also in the process of selling my UK property, which may release approximately £200,000 in equity. I would therefore expect to have substantial settlement funds available, potentially CAD $300,000+ immediately accessible, with further funds available if required.
I would be seeking to relocate permanently, work in Canada, establish housing, enrol the children in school, integrate into the community, and build a long-term life there.
The key issue is that I am very concerned about being reported at the border for breach of the residency obligation. I would like advice on the likely process if this happens, including whether I would be allowed to enter Canada as a PR, whether a removal order could be issued, whether I would have a right of appeal to the Immigration Appeal Division, and how strong or weak my H&C case would realistically be.

I appreciate this is a long read, I look forward to hearing from you.
What HC reason ? People use HC far far too casually. You haven’t lived in the country for 20 plus years . You’re in your mid 30’s . You can’t say you have any meaningful connection to Canada when you were only here for a year and you were a teenager.
How would you enroll the children in school ? Healthcare ?
Do you have a SIN ? If you don’t have a SIN how would you work ?

“I am currently based in the UK and have a senior professional role as a Director in the property/real estate sector, earning a six-figure income. I am also in the process of selling my UK property, which may release approximately £200,000 in equity. I would therefore expect to have substantial settlement funds available, potentially CAD $300,000+ immediately accessible, with further funds available if required”
Irrelevant

Adding , why now ? You’ve established yourself in your country . This should have been done when you were around 18, not a decade and a half later .
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: YVR123
What HC reason ? People use HC far far too casually. You haven’t lived in the country for 20 plus years . You’re in your mid 30’s . You can’t say you have any meaningful connection to Canada when you were only here for a year and you were a teenager.
How would you enroll the children in school ? Healthcare ?
Do you have a SIN ? If you don’t have a SIN how would you work ?

“I am currently based in the UK and have a senior professional role as a Director in the property/real estate sector, earning a six-figure income. I am also in the process of selling my UK property, which may release approximately £200,000 in equity. I would therefore expect to have substantial settlement funds available, potentially CAD $300,000+ immediately accessible, with further funds available if required”
Irrelevant

Adding , why now ? You’ve established yourself in your country . This should have been done when you were around 18, not a decade and a half later .

I dont know what H&C grounds, I'm assuming the lawyer was suggesting that I left when I was a child.

Thanks for your reply but it hasn't given me any direction, what would you do?
Other than 'stay in your country'
 
I dont know what H&C grounds, I'm assuming the lawyer was suggesting that I left when I was a child.

Thanks for your reply but it hasn't given me any direction, what would you do?
Other than 'stay in your country'

Your plan has many issues. You may have H&C reasons if you were removed as child but returned as soon as possible to age 18. How are the children of your partner going to live in Canada? If you get really lucky and aren’t reported you should wait 2 years before sponsoring your partner, her child and your children together so they can get PR.
 
  • Like
Reactions: YVR123
I dont know what H&C grounds, I'm assuming the lawyer was suggesting that I left when I was a child.

Thanks for your reply but it hasn't given me any direction, what would you do?
Other than 'stay in your country'
I don't think your plan is realistic at all. You probably don't have any strong H&C grounds ('removed when a child' - well, you've been an adult for 10+ years and not tried to return before this). If you get through at border, you'd really have to/best wait a couple years before applying for a PR card. Work, health insurance, basics of life might be a problem for you, worse for your spouse and children. Too much here dependent on chance, and quite likely not a lifestyle in the interim that would be good for a family (lifestyle they're used to, etc).

If you are really interested in moving to Canada, you could look into qualifying as an economic applicant - if you can qualify. That would involve renouncing your PR status first (or having it revoked). Before doing that, you may wish to look into how to qualify, and possibly consult an immigration lawyer.
 
I dont know what H&C grounds, I'm assuming the lawyer was suggesting that I left when I was a child.

Thanks for your reply but it hasn't given me any direction, what would you do?
Other than 'stay in your country'
I clearly stated what you may come up against
No healthcare, no job , no access to education
And your lawyer has no clue