+1(514) 937-9445 or Toll-free (Canada & US) +1 (888) 947-9445

ustocanada49

Star Member
Jan 6, 2017
165
17
Hi,
Thanks in advance for your replies.
I only have lived in Canada for 3-4 months after landing on PR. Can I enter Canada with only 1 year left on PR card expiry date? Considering the fact that I have met only a few months out of 2 years minimum residency requirement and won't be able to achieve this obligation within the 1 year time left on PR card.
 
Hi,
Thanks in advance for your replies.
I only have lived in Canada for 3-4 months after landing on PR. Can I enter Canada with only 1 year left on PR card expiry date? Considering the fact that I have met only a few months out of 2 years minimum residency requirement and won't be able to achieve this obligation within the 1 year time left on PR card.
You are allowed to enter and there will be no questions asked at entry point. My wife and kid travelled with only 2 months left before expiry and have not met RO. We stayed here for 2 years and then applied PR Renewal. We are now waiting for the PR Cards to collect.
 
Hi,
Thanks in advance for your replies.
I only have lived in Canada for 3-4 months after landing on PR. Can I enter Canada with only 1 year left on PR card expiry date? Considering the fact that I have met only a few months out of 2 years minimum residency requirement and won't be able to achieve this obligation within the 1 year time left on PR card.

I personally was harassed/bullied by CBSA and sent to secondary inspection from day one, whenever crossed the border by land. Each time at land POE I was aggressively grilled for 20 minutes about my residence. Note that this happened to me when I was a brand new PR in Canada, with plenty of time left to fulfill RO. I never crossed into Canada in breach of RO. It's hard to say how you will be treated at the border. If you have dark brown skin, or if you are female, or if you are a man dressed as woman, or belong to some other protected group of people/minorities (not all minorities are protected, I must add), then chances are they will let you in without much scrutiny. Protected groups of people usually receive preferential treatment. I am a male and don't belong to protected group of minorities, and I was harshly treated, profiled and harassed at the border (scapegoated, to use the proper term).

Some members, as you can see, report being treated nicely , even though they are in serious breach of RO (I wasn't in breach of anything).
Each case is therefore different. It's hard to say how you will be treated by CBSA. But , as I noted above, if you belong to protected minority class then chances are you will be admitted without much trouble, even though you are in breach of RO.
 
Last edited:
You are allowed to enter and there will be no questions asked at entry point. My wife and kid travelled with only 2 months left before expiry and have not met RO. We stayed here for 2 years and then applied PR Renewal. We are now waiting for the PR Cards to collect.

Whether or not there will be questions asked - and indeed whether there will be any issue made about the non-compliance with the residency obligation - is basically up to the border agent. (You absolutely did the right thing by remaining in Canada to get compliant and then applying to renew, though). So some won't have it as eaisly as you apparently did.

It could be nothing (waved through), just some questions and possibly a verbal warning, or up to and including much longer with a report for non-compliance (that could result in revocation of PR status, albeit subject to appeal).

So anyone coming should be aware and prepared - if asked why out of compliance, explain why (covid, personal reasons, whatever). There is at least some anecdotal evidence that they are being somewhat more lenient with covid travel issues having complicated things for many, but that wont' apply in all cases.
 
  • Like
Reactions: YVR123
You are allowed to enter and there will be no questions asked at entry point. My wife and kid travelled with only 2 months left before expiry and have not met RO. We stayed here for 2 years and then applied PR Renewal. We are now waiting for the PR Cards to collect.
Hi Prasanth,
So, you were in Canada already when your wife and children entered?
 
I only have lived in Canada for 3-4 months after landing on PR. Can I enter Canada with only 1 year left on PR card expiry date? Considering the fact that I have met only a few months out of 2 years minimum residency requirement and won't be able to achieve this obligation within the 1 year time left on PR card.

Depending on when you received the PR card in relation to when you landed, your lack of RO compliance may be even more pronounced than indicated by the post.
 
  • Like
Reactions: canuck78
Hi,
Thanks in advance for your replies.
I only have lived in Canada for 3-4 months after landing on PR. Can I enter Canada with only 1 year left on PR card expiry date? Considering the fact that I have met only a few months out of 2 years minimum residency requirement and won't be able to achieve this obligation within the 1 year time left on PR card.

Your RO is 730 days since you landed it doesn't have anything to do with the ecpiry of your PR card.
 
Hi,
Thanks in advance for your replies.
I only have lived in Canada for 3-4 months after landing on PR. Can I enter Canada with only 1 year left on PR card expiry date? Considering the fact that I have met only a few months out of 2 years minimum residency requirement and won't be able to achieve this obligation within the 1 year time left on PR card.

You will be allowed to enter Canada.

Whether you are asked questions about compliance with the Residency Obligation, and if so whether that leads to you being Reported (including issued a Departure or Removal Order), cannot be easily predicted. Currently, and during the pandemic, border control appears to have been more lenient toward arriving PRs who are in breach of the PR Residency Obligation, which obviously you are. The scope of that leniency is uncertain. It appears there has been quite a lot of leniency toward PRs with a valid PR card and still within the first five years after landing.

That not only could end any day, it will end without notice and well before we see clear indication of that in this forum (so, it could have already ended . . . or it may be continuing, for a little while, perhaps longer, we just do not know).

At this juncture, gambling odds probably lean toward betting it will go OK, but the sooner you arrive the better your odds. And of course once here you will need to stay, in order to keep your PR status, until in compliance.

Regarding this:

You are allowed to enter and there will be no questions asked at entry point.

Yes, allowed to enter. But, at the risk of being picky, perhaps even a bit harsh, EVERY ADULT is asked questions when entering Canada. It is simply NOT anywhere near true that "there will be no questions asked at entry point."

I get it, @prasanth reddy probably means questions about RO compliance, and it does appear that even PRs in breach of the RO are often waived into Canada without being closely questioned about RO compliance. To be clear, however, there will be some questions, and returning PRs can be questioned about RO compliance. And for sure some are questioned about RO compliance, even in the current environment which, again, appears to be rather lenient relative to border control screening PR's in regards to RO compliance.

Moreover, border officials often ask indirect questions, and not only can be but usually, typically, are asking questions relevant to a range of matters, probing to determine if there is reason to probe further. Border officials often deliberately avoid telegraphing just what it is they are asking about.

The extent of questioning will vary widely from individual to individual. It will vary depending on circumstances. It will vary depending on how the PR-traveler responds to questions. It can vary depending on the particular officer's discretion. It will vary depending on what is the focus of enforcement at that Port-of-Entry for that day or week.

For the PR in breach of the RO, best to be prepared to answer questions about how long they have been abroad, and importantly WHY, and to be prepared to otherwise make the case they are coming to Canada to STAY as soon as they practically could.
 
Thanks very much for your opinions guys. Thinking of contacting an attorney to help in case I need it at the time of entry
 
Thanks very much for your opinions guys. Thinking of contacting an attorney to help in case I need it at the time of entry

Make sure you contact a licensed attorney, not an immigration consultant. While attorney is not Emperor Caligula and can't order CBSA to grant you instant pass without questions, still, he can advise you about your rights and options.

 
Last edited: