Difference in Basic Residence & Physical Residence
- Thread starter punk
- Start date
Basic residence is how long you've been a permanent resident of Canada. Physical residence is the days you've actually lived in Canada. You need to meet both requirements to apply for citizenship. If you apply for citizenship and only meet the basic residency requirements (but not the physical residency requirements) - then you can expect your application to be refused.
punk said:
That can happen only if you never left Canada (for more than one day to the US), in which case basic residence equals physical residence.
punk said:
You need to meet the physical residency requirements. Meeting basic residency isn't enough.
punk said:
I don't know why or when the wording was changed, but in the past there were cases when people applied for citizenship with full basic residency, but very little physical residency. One example was a permanent resident who went to college in the United States and applied for Canadian citizenship after spending only a few hundred days (possibly under 300, can't remember the exact amount) in Canada. In these cases, citizenship was granted by the discretion of a citizenship judge, and I believe this practice was pretty unpopular among Canadians. CIC's current practice is to not do this, and people who apply with less than 1095 days -- even if it is just a few days less -- will find themselves either refused, or shunted into the RQ processing stream for extended processing followed by a probable refusal. People who have a real reason why they will never be able to accumulate 1095 days (airline pilots, maybe others) might be able to succeed in these circumstances -- but that is not the same as a student who studies in a foreign country. A consultant who travels a lot would have to make a compelling case as to their ties in Canada, and I don't know if that sort of application could succeed.
punk said:
No need to be confused. Basic residence is the time elapsed since the moment you landed. Physical residence counts the number of days you've been in Canada for a time windows of 4 years. That's it.
punk said:
The wording wasn't changed. Basic and physical residency are two different things. See my first answer to your post above.
This was my point. I travel a lot but I am owner of a company based in Canada. So in case of basic residence, I can just mention, that I have been paying rental, insurance and other expenses in Canada because I was tied to Canada can qualify if the judge agrees?
Now i started to hate C-24 more and more
Now i started to hate C-24 more and more
punk said:
Not sure how physical residency is affected, but they can find out that you were not physically present in Canada through the CBSA report.
punk said:
One can only hope the residency provision of C-24 won't come into effect until, say, 2016, but that's not too safe an assumption. We're all frustrated...
Hope it works out as we plannedSimilar threads
