Thanks again for a informative reply.A common problem in this forum is the proliferation of observations, even outright advice, which makes a declarative statement that is often true but also more than occasionally NOT true . . . not true because there are other factors or circumstances which affect how things go.
And then there are those responses which totally gloss over what can happen based on a perception (some accurate, many not-so-accurate) about how such cases USUALLY go . . . "you'll be FINE." And indeed, many if not most typically are "fine," depending on what that means. But that can be dangerously misleading for more than a few.
Your family, for example, they won the appeal. They are in Canada. It is easy to say "they will be fine." And it is likely they will indeed be fine.
That is unless they go live abroad before they meet the Residency Obligation.
NO, days in Canada since the 44(1) report do NOT count in determining whether that report was valid in law. Only days prior to the date of the 44(1) Report are counted in that calculation. If you were short of meeting the RO as of that day, the report will be found to be valid in law.
If the report is determined (by IAD) to be valid in law, then H&C factors will be considered in determining whether you should be allowed to retain PR status DESPITE the breach of the RO.
THEN your days in Canada since the 44(44(1) report will be considered in the analysis of H&C reasons, and they should help (assuming you have mostly been in Canada during this time) make the case that you should be allowed another chance to keep PR status. The fact your family is settled in Canada in the meantime should help as well.
I think I have specifically explained this in response to your queries before.
If I consider last 5 yrs... before a44(1) report my stay is 8 months and then I left to India and came in 2018 and now almost 14 months...in 2 months total stay will be 2 yrs in last 5years.
If I am allowed to stay in CAnada on H&C basis..will all these days of stay can be counted if in future I apply for Citizenship? Or say renewal of PR card?
And if I am not communicated by Minister delegate in coming months and if I complete 2 years stay in last 5 years...can I get a 5 year card? Even still I'm under a44(1) report?