+1(514) 937-9445 or Toll-free (Canada & US) +1 (888) 947-9445
Client Portal

Recent content by ra2258

  1. R

    Was My Mother Deemed a Citizen in 1947 Under Section 5(1)(b)?

    That's funny. My experience was similar. It gave me that reference (which could have been super useful). I kept asking it to show me where it got it. I kept at it and at it. Basically saying if you said this - SHOW ME. It (finally) admitted (or said) it was old training data. But I had to push...
  2. R

    Was My Mother Deemed a Citizen in 1947 Under Section 5(1)(b)?

    Agree 100% and I did my own research, which was fun and I learned quite a bit, and used AI to sanity check stuff. I have no doubt that was a real artifact. But no idea if it is still in affect or valid. Thanks again for all the help and input - it is most appreciated!!
  3. R

    Was My Mother Deemed a Citizen in 1947 Under Section 5(1)(b)?

    I think you are 100% correct. Yes - the goal is to get citizenship. I know the new bill will (probably) make this easier for me but that is an unknown. Will decide whether to submit with the 1095 days (straight submission), ask for a grant/exception or just wait. Thank you!!
  4. R

    Was My Mother Deemed a Citizen in 1947 Under Section 5(1)(b)?

    I really appreciate you taking the time to respond. I think if I ignore all of this (my weird legal theory, merchant marine services, etc.) I still have a solid chance of obtaining citizenship given the current situation as my mother clearly is now considered a citizen.... On that reference -...
  5. R

    Was My Mother Deemed a Citizen in 1947 Under Section 5(1)(b)?

    After reviewing the documents and researching the Canadian National Steamship Company, it appears my grandfather was indeed in Crown service when my mother was born in 1937. Key findings: He served as a Steward on the Lady Hawkins (CNS vessel) during documented wartime voyages in 1940-1941...
  6. R

    Was My Mother Deemed a Citizen in 1947 Under Section 5(1)(b)?

    It's close. But we do not know for sure. After my grandfather was killed, they did less and less time there. There were issues with his benefits between my grandmother and his parents. I know his parents wanted to see their grandkids. And that he wanted to make sure my mom got Canadian...
  7. R

    Was My Mother Deemed a Citizen in 1947 Under Section 5(1)(b)?

    I truly appreciate you taking the time to reply. One last comment / question to folks... I know the general rule is: if your parent was born outside Canada, you’re second gen. But I’m wondering if there’s a key exception for people like my mother — born abroad before 1947 to a Canadian-born...
  8. R

    Was My Mother Deemed a Citizen in 1947 Under Section 5(1)(b)?

    Wow - I did not know that about the Canadian Merchant Marine - Thanks! I did confirm with my Mom and my grandparents met when he was a purser on a cruise ship. So no, he was not a crown servant...he was drafted, conscripted or volunteered to serve (as did his brother who was in the Royal Navy).
  9. R

    Was My Mother Deemed a Citizen in 1947 Under Section 5(1)(b)?

    Thanks — I appreciate your take. That’s definitely possible, and we’ll pursue the interim measure if needed. I guess what I’m still hoping to clarify is how to confirm what IRCC actually determined when they issued my mother’s certificate. It seems like the 1 Jan 1947 effective date doesn’t...
  10. R

    Was My Mother Deemed a Citizen in 1947 Under Section 5(1)(b)?

    Thanks to everyone for the responses ( @hawk39 @canuck78 @armoured ) — I appreciate the input and want to clarify what I’m trying to understand. My mother was born in the U.S. in 1937 to a Canadian-born father. She later applied to IRCC and received a Proof of Canadian Citizenship certificate...
  11. R

    Was My Mother Deemed a Citizen in 1947 Under Section 5(1)(b)?

    I'm trying to confirm how IRCC is likely to classify my mother's citizenship — specifically, whether she was deemed a Canadian citizen on January 1, 1947 under section 5(1)(b) of the original Canadian Citizenship Act. Key facts: My grandfather was born in Canada and served in the Canadian...
  12. R

    First vs Second Generation – Mother's 1947 Citizenship Status

    I'm seeking clarification on whether I'm considered first or second generation born abroad for Canadian citizenship purposes, as this directly affects my eligibility for citizenship by descent. Background: Grandfather: Born in Canada; served in the Canadian Merchant Marines during WWII; KIA in...
See more