Parent's visitor visa rejected twice, I have ODN but won't apply for GCMS notes, Which option i can choose here to get reasoning behind rejection

[krishnadhanani456]

Parent's visitor visa rejected twice, I have ODN but want apply for GCMS notes, Which option i can choose here (https://atip-aiprp.apps.gc.ca/) to get proper reasoning behind rejection reason.

Rejection reason:
Thank you for your interest in coming to Canada. I have reviewed your temporary resident visa (visitor visa) application and supporting documentation to assess whether you meet the requirements for a visitor visa (
https://www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/services/visit-canada/eligibility.html
). This includes assessing whether you are coming to Canada temporarily for the reason(s) you describe in your application. I have determined that your application does not meet the requirements of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA) (
https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/I-2.5/index.html
) and Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations (IRPR) (
https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/regulations/sor-2002-227/index.html
).

I am refusing your application.
• I am not satisfied that you will leave Canada at the end of your stay as required by paragraph 179(b) of the IRPR (
https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/regulations/SOR-2002-227/section-179.html
). I am refusing your application because you have not established that you will leave Canada, based on the following factors:
• The purpose of your visit to Canada is not consistent with a temporary stay given the details you have provided in your application.

 

[Naturgrl]

Officer's notes.
1. How long was visit?
2. What did they show that they will return?
3. What was purpose of visit and itinerary.

They have 2 refusals so show that they will return - job letter with approved leave, business, income property etc. If visit is too long then refused too.

 

[krishnadhanani456]

Officer's notes.
1. How long was visit?
2. What did they show that they will return?
3. What was purpose of visit and itinerary.

They have 2 refusals so show that they will return - job letter with approved leave, business, income property etc. If visit is too long then refused too.

Thanks for reply!!

1. How long was visit = 1 month
2. What did they show that they will return = Son's wedding next year (2027), care giver of elderly mother and ongoing business activity
3. What was purpose of visit and itinerary = We didn't mentioned any itinerary, (I have mentined they will stay with me at my home during their stay)
Purpose of visit : Family visit and sightseeing to explore Canadian culture and tourist attractions.

We added proof of own house, agriculture land and business,

Anything we can improve here ?

 

[canuck78]

Thanks for reply!!

1. How long was visit = 1 month
2. What did they show that they will return = Son's wedding next year (2027), care giver of elderly mother and ongoing business activity
3. What was purpose of visit and itinerary = We didn't mentioned any itinerary, (I have mentined they will stay with me at my home during their stay)
Purpose of visit : Family visit and sightseeing to explore Canadian culture and tourist attractions.

We added proof of own house, agriculture land and business,

Anything we can improve here ?

Where are they from? How much personal savings have they shown? 2 months a long time if the tie is a business snd caring for elderly mother. Where does the brother live and has he ever applied to live abroad if he lived in his home country? Have they travelled internationally before especially to countries like US, UK, Australia, etc. What is your status in Canada and how long have you lived here?

 

[Naturgrl]

Thanks for reply!!

1. How long was visit = 1 month
2. What did they show that they will return = Son's wedding next year (2027), care giver of elderly mother and ongoing business activity
3. What was purpose of visit and itinerary = We didn't mentioned any itinerary, (I have mentined they will stay with me at my home during their stay)
Purpose of visit : Family visit and sightseeing to explore Canadian culture and tourist attractions.

We added proof of own house, agriculture land and business,

Anything we can improve here ?

1. Visit too long. Keep to 2 weeks.
2. The only tie is their business. So it is in both their names only and they showed business registration, taxes paid, client invoices etc. They don't have family ties to return.
3. So they had no plan for one month. Yeah, IRCC doesn't think they will leave.

 

[krishnadhanani456]

1. Visit too long. Keep to 2 weeks.
2. The only tie is their business. So it is in both their names only and they showed business registration, taxes paid, client invoices etc. They don't have family ties to return.
3. So they had no plan for one month. Yeah, IRCC doesn't think they will leave.

Regarding family ties, we have already mentioned that my parents have strong family connections in India, including their son and my grandmother, they are Indian citizens and have lived in India their entire lives. They also have all of their assets and established life in India.

What other evidence can we provide to further demonstrate their strong family ties to their home country?

Also, since they will be staying with me at my home in Canada, is it still necessary to prepare a detailed travel itinerary?

 

[krishnadhanani456]

Where are they from? How much personal savings have they shown? 2 months a long time if the tie is a business snd caring for elderly mother. Where does the brother live and has he ever applied to live abroad if he lived in his home country? Have they travelled internationally before especially to countries like US, UK, Australia, etc. What is your status in Canada and how long have you lived here?

Thanks for reply!!

- They are from india
- How much personal savings have they shown : around 21,000 CAD for 1 month visit (they will be staying with me at my home in Canada during their stay)
- Brother : Currently he lives in india with parents, but he was in canada on study permit and work permit for around 3 years ( 2020-2024) and left canada before his work permit expire, But i haven't mentioned that brother lived here on study permit and work permit in application.

- Have they travelled internationally before: No

- My status in Canada: I have PR, Living here since Oct 2022, I haven't applied for super visa as they don't have any plan to stay here for long time,they just wan't to visit canada only once

 

[Naturgrl]

Regarding family ties, we have already mentioned that my parents have strong family connections in India, including their son and my grandmother, they are Indian citizens and have lived in India their entire lives. They also have all of their assets and established life in India.

What other evidence can we provide to further demonstrate their strong family ties to their home country?

Also, since they will be staying with me at my home in Canada, is it still necessary to prepare a detailed travel itinerary?

So family connections are spouse and children under 22. They don't have strong family connections if you are in Canada and PR. Grandmother is not a tie. Their ties to return are jobs with approved leave, business in their name only, income property with leases.

Yes they need an itinerary. Show they have a plan with an end date.