FSW WORLDWIDE

[RSub]

https://www.cicnews.com/2023/02/ircc-unveils-the-top-10-source-countries-of-new-immigrants-to-canada-in-2022-0233180.html#gs.5x6l5e

India sends only 27% of immigrants/PRs.

For my own research, I want to know why did you say 80% are from India?

But, it feels like 80%. Coz, not a single hour pass by without seeing 10 Indians or someone who like Indian every day. Its like they are everywhere and it has created an illusion that Canada is occupied by Indians. Sometimes, even as an Indian, I get confused between Pakistanis and North Indians, Srilankans and Tamils, & Asians and North Eastern Indians. I cannot tell who is who.

 

[RSub]

Ah man! I hope now Modi does not stop sending wheat flour and basmati rice now. Had a lot of trouble last year and this year. I HATE non-Indian rice, it never feels right in texture and taste. And flour.... Less is said the better. Get ready for some pricey food again if you eat Indian food!

At least, prices of Basmati rice hasn't gone up. Right now paying twice what I paid for a 20 pound rice bag. And my mom and wife wanted me to throw the rice away as it does not taste like the brand we used to get previously.

 

[abhiram.kumar]

So you see no problem with Indian landlords renting only to Indians?


Nothing racist with wanting a more balanced immigration system.

When the large majority of immigrants are coming from one single country it's no longer immigration but invasion.

We are seeing right now the impact of having massive numbers coming from one place when immigrants start bringing internal disputes from their country of origin to Canada.

I'm all for multiculturalism, diversity, etc, but that ceases to exist when one single country is the source of the majority of immigrants by such large margins.

Regarding India and China being the most populated countries, just because there are more of them, does Canada also have to have more of them?

Do our demographics have to reflect global demographics?

As an Indian, I fully agree with your statement. Recent events are a perfect example as to how the Canadian government has fucked up the multicultural experiment. Immigrants are not expected to bring their trash from their home countries. Canada doesn’t expect assimilation but integration. Integration cannot happen when you bring in too many people within a short period of time. I think it’s time for everyone in Canada to wake up to the fact that mass immigration without integration is a disaster.

 

[abhiram.kumar]

But, it feels like 80%. Coz, not a single hour pass by without seeing 10 Indians or someone who like Indian every day. Its like they are everywhere and it has created an illusion that Canada is occupied by Indians. Sometimes, even as an Indian, I get confused between Pakistanis and North Indians, Srilankans and Tamils, & Asians and North Eastern Indians. I cannot tell who is who.

I get the feeling is because while Indian immigrants are only 30% of the annual numbers, the vast majority of international students are Indians. People have started conflating international students with immigrants. When you combine both, it feels like that there are a lot of Indians in Canada.

 

[RSub]

Indians are overstaying though. Several Indian international students are staying in Canada undocumented and they work under the table. I have personally seen certain students do this. If you look at the asylum claims statistics of Canada, Indians are among the top asylum claimants. Let’s admit the truth. We Indians are not as great as what we would like to portray to the world. We are the same as everyone else. Our shit doesn’t smell better than others and no matter how much you see the so called patriotic NRIs in Canada bitch about the living costs and life over here, most of them will never even entertain the thought about leaving Canada to go back to India permanently. They all know that it’s a shithole. The reality is that it isn’t the obligation of Canada or any other western country to provide jobs and a better life for our youth. We fucked up as a country and our young don’t give a crap about staying back and are looking at every opportunity to get the fuck out.

What reason are they using for Asylum? Pathetic and lame to use asylum route.

 

[navinball]

I think the target of 1 million per year is too low. If they want to be an economic and political superpower they need at least a population of 150-200 million by 2100 to compete with usa for world domination.

 

[abhiram.kumar]

I think the target of 1 million per year is too low. If they want to be an economic and political superpower they need at least a population of 150-200 million by 2100 to compete with usa for world domination.

This is not even geographically feasible because Northern Canada is not habitable and food cannot be grown over there.

 

[Arod]

As an Indian, I fully agree with your statement. Recent events are a perfect example as to how the Canadian government has fucked up the multicultural experiment. Immigrants are not expected to bring their trash from their home countries. Canada doesn’t expect assimilation but integration. Integration cannot happen when you bring in too many people within a short period of time. I think it’s time for everyone in Canada to wake up to the fact that mass immigration without integration is a disaster.

Exactly, if you are moving here leave the trash home.

 

[Arod]

I think the target of 1 million per year is too low. If they want to be an economic and political superpower they need at least a population of 150-200 million by 2100 to compete with usa for world domination.

It would be a mistake for Canada to increase its population by so much without a proper plan.

I constantly read in online forums many Americans complaining that their country is overpopulated and that their quality of life would be better if there was less people.

 

[navinball]

This is not even geographically feasible because Northern Canada is not habitable and food cannot be grown over there.

habitable land is not an issue. there is plenty. a 200 km strip along the border of usa is more than the area of pakistan or bangladesh.

 

[RSub]

Exactly, if you are moving here leave the trash home.

Unfortunately, for many, the trash is inbuilt.

 

[ravyn]

Ministerial Instructions respecting invitations to apply for permanent residence under the Express Entry system #264– September 20, 2023

See full text of Ministerial Instruction

Transport occupations (2023-1)

Number of invitations issued: 1,000Footnote*

Rank required to be invited to apply: 1,000 or above

Date and time of round: September 20, 2023 at 14:04:14 UTC

CRS score of lowest-ranked candidate invited: 435

Tie-breaking rule: June 17, 2023 at 06:44:01 UTC


Decently low score for transportation applicants

 

[GandiBaat]

So you see no problem with Indian landlords renting only to Indians?


Nothing racist with wanting a more balanced immigration system.

When the large majority of immigrants are coming from one single country it's no longer immigration but invasion.

We are seeing right now the impact of having massive numbers coming from one place when immigrants start bringing internal disputes from their country of origin to Canada.

I'm all for multiculturalism, diversity, etc, but that ceases to exist when one single country is the source of the majority of immigrants by such large margins.

Regarding India and China being the most populated countries, just because there are more of them, does Canada also have to have more of them?

Do our demographics have to reflect global demographics?

Okay, first things first. You became a PR in 2020 from what I can tell. Are you already a citizen? I am somewhat doubtful. So "our demographics" is a bit premature. Its Canadian demographics.

Now "balanced immigration". What does it mean? Balanced according to what you define as balanced? Canada has a policy of raising population to 100M and I do not see it happening without significant help from India and China. Its a simple question of practicality. You can disagree with their 100M goal but then for that you need to be a citizen.

Secondly, "Invasion"... Are you REAL? Canada got much higher rate (%age of population) of immigration in the past. Except all of them were from Europe. Will you call it a European invasion of Canada? Or is it the nationality or something similar that is troubling you.

Further, Canada has this nice "Charter of Freedom" and "CAnadian values":

"15. (1) Every individual is equal before and under the law and has the right to the equal protection and equal benefit of the law without discrimination and, in particular, without discrimination based on race, national or ethnic origin, colour, religion, sex, age or mental or physical disability."

Before you ask, yes, this has been applied to immigrants as well. Canadian courts have turned decisions of IRCC which violated these. Its called "Canadian Values" and yeah not discriminating based on national or ethnic origin is a part of it.

So forget it if you want Canada to limit immigration based on national or ethnic origin. NOT GONNA HAPPEN!

If you so desperately wanted that, there is USA just south. They seems to do it your way.

 

[GandiBaat]

As an Indian, I fully agree with your statement. Recent events are a perfect example as to how the Canadian government has fucked up the multicultural experiment. Immigrants are not expected to bring their trash from their home countries. Canada doesn’t expect assimilation but integration. Integration cannot happen when you bring in too many people within a short period of time. I think it’s time for everyone in Canada to wake up to the fact that mass immigration without integration is a disaster.

Are you for real as well?

You talk about integration, you have not even read the Canadian Charter of Freedom and Canadian values!

 

[Arod]

Okay, first things first. You became a PR in 2020 from what I can tell. Are you already a citizen? I am somewhat doubtful. So "our demographics" is a bit premature. Its Canadian demographics.

Now "balanced immigration". What does it mean? Balanced according to what you define as balanced? Canada has a policy of raising population to 100M and I do not see it happening without significant help from India and China. Its a simple question of practicality. You can disagree with their 100M goal but then for that you need to be a citizen.

Secondly, "Invasion"... Are you REAL? Canada got much higher rate (%age of population) of immigration in the past. Except all of them were from Europe. Will you call it a European invasion of Canada? Or is it the nationality or something similar that is troubling you.

Further, Canada has this nice "Charter of Freedom" and "CAnadian values":

"15. (1) Every individual is equal before and under the law and has the right to the equal protection and equal benefit of the law without discrimination and, in particular, without discrimination based on race, national or ethnic origin, colour, religion, sex, age or mental or physical disability."

Before you ask, yes, this has been applied to immigrants as well. Canadian courts have turned decisions of IRCC which violated these. Its called "Canadian Values" and yeah not discriminating based on national or ethnic origin is a part of it.

So forget it if you want Canada to limit immigration based on national or ethnic origin. NOT GONNA HAPPEN!

If you so desperately wanted that, there is USA just south. They seems to do it your way.

What does me being a citizen have to do with anything?

Also, why are you looking at my history? That is just creepy.

I'll save you some time, I became a PR before 2020 and I'm a citizen now. I also got 20 out of 20 in the citizenship test, so please don't try to teach us lessons here.

What is wrong with wanting a more balanced immigration system? Or is it that you want Canada to become India 2.0?