URGENT help: 2nd TRV/TRP for kids application after 1st rejected

[Yorker13]

Hi ,

I am a PR since May 2013, same thing for my wife and son, I am in canada since 2016 and inline with RO ,which is not the case for my wife and son.

we have 2 girls born ourside of Canada and they dont have PR, I applied for TRV for them on 2016 to come along with my wife and son ,but i couldnt find job so they return back and my wife got back to her old job,

I applied again for TRV/TRP in Jan 2018,and it was rejected in March 2018, with unlogical reasons, like.

1- there is risk the girls will not leave canada after trv expires.
2-contacts in canada.
3-contacts in UAE.
4-no enough funds.

i been working since november 2016, and when i applied first time for TRP i was not working ,and i was in UAE.

why they change their minds?

now ,i spoken to a consultant and he urged me to immediately apply for Family sponsorship for my 2 child daughters,then renew my PR card, then reapply again proving u r sponsoring ur kids and u want them to stay while their PR is being processed

i need ur suggestions how to make my case stronger, my wife and son PR card will expire in July 2018, my wife have strong reasons for not meeting her RO, like her father died or colon cancer and she stayed with him during his treatment period until he passed away,

also she is a nurse and she got diploma and to work as nurse in canada u need to get bachelor which she did take while working there to support the family,

now i want my family to come all together, my wife cant leave 3 and 4 years young kids behind,

any suggestion before i send the new application, what points shall i add, is there any thing else i can do to make the application more convincing,?

i dont have reference number for the PR renewal or Family sponsorhip application,i only have the official receipt, which dont have a discretion on it? is that enough proof as reference for such applications?

 

[Yorker13]

up

 

[Bryanna]

I applied again for TRV/TRP in Jan 2018,and it was rejected in March 2018, with unlogical reasons, like.

1- there is risk the girls will not leave canada after trv expires.
2-contacts in canada.
3-contacts in UAE.
4-no enough funds.

Although it might seem illogical, IRCC has valid reasons to refuse your younger children. Also, they were given an opportunity earlier to come to Canada (and you could have applied for their PRs).

now ,i spoken to a consultant and he urged me to immediately apply for Family sponsorship for my 2 child daughters,then renew my PR card, then reapply again proving u r sponsoring ur kids and u want them to stay while their PR is being processed

You can apply to sponsor them after you meet residency obligations.

i need ur suggestions how to make my case stronger, my wife and son PR card will expire in July 2018, my wife have strong reasons for not meeting her RO, like her father died or colon cancer and she stayed with him during his treatment period until he passed away,

For H&C grounds, IRCC will evaluate reasons and evidence for the last 5 years:
Did her dad have any other immediate family members who lived with him?
Can your wife prove that she was the sole caregiver?
Can she prove that she did not have other reasons to return/remain in the UAE? Based on your posts, it seems like there were three reasons: You were not employed + she has been working in the UAE all these years + she was studying for a bachelor's degree.

It's best if your wife consults an immigration lawyer to see if she qualifies on H&C grounds to keep her PR status. Otherwise it would be better if she and your son renounce their PR. You can then sponsor your wife + all your children together after you meet RO

 

[Yorker13]

Hi Bryanna,

thanks a lot for your answers,

Although it might seem illogical, IRCC has valid reasons to refuse your younger children. Also, they were given an opportunity earlier to come to Canada (and you could have applied for their PRs).



You can apply to sponsor them after you meet residency obligations.

I did, as I explained in my post, after consuluting a specialist ,she advised me to renew my PR card, then apply to sponsor the kids, which I did, but i dont have a reference number since i sent the applications in May 2018 and IRCC still didnt recieve the documents, the only way to prove it is by the official receipt.

I did include these details in the explanation letter to apply again for TRP.

I was asking what further documents shall i include to make my case stronger and revert their first decision?

For H&C grounds, IRCC will evaluate reasons and evidence for the last 5 years:
Did her dad have any other immediate family members who lived with him?
Can your wife prove that she was the sole caregiver?
Can she prove that she did not have other reasons to return/remain in the UAE? Based on your posts, it seems like there were three reasons: You were not employed + she has been working in the UAE all these years + she was studying for a bachelor's degree.

It's best if your wife consults an immigration lawyer to see if she qualifies on H&C grounds to keep her PR status. Otherwise it would be better if she and your son renounce their PR. You can then sponsor your wife + all your children together after you meet RO

my wife's PR card will expire in end of July 2018, she have limited time to enter Canada, but becuz of the 2 daughters last TRV/trp refusal she will be there until they get permission to enter canada

when her father was being treated from the colon cancer my wife was the only working person among her siblings,after few months from the date he passed away ,her sibling started to get jobs but not good ones,until this date, she gives her mother and siblings half of her salary but the problem is ,she cash the money ,so there is no bank transaction to prove that....!!!

yes,one of the other reasons why she still there was becuz i couldnt find job in my field of study,so it was economically better for us she continues working there.

will her case comlplicate the TRV/TRP of our 2 daughters? why the embassy is concerned of meeting RO, shouldnt that be the job of IRCC not embassy, even though , each PR have the right to enter Canada,at least to explain him/herself in the court..!!?

my last question if u dont mind

can I renew the PR card of my son who also was there in UAE with his mother all this time, i mean renewing his PR card only not my wife as well,
since he is a minor ,and he dont have a choice ,he was accompying his mother, and now I am in the process of renewing my PR card, can i renew his PR card and would it be successful since he didnt live here in the past 5 years?

i will explain that he accompyed his mother,who have H&C reasons, and I am inline with RO would that be enough or would IRCC show lienancy toward minors to renew their PR card?


thank you Bryanna

 

[scylla]

Your wife's H&C reasons aren't strong unfortunately. It sounds like there were many other family members there to take care of her father - she wasn't the only relative. She could have worked in Canada instead if financial support was required. Also, the fact her siblings weren't working really doesn't support an H&C argument for her. You should expect this is how IRCC will view the situation. Good luck.

 

[Yorker13]

how about my son's PR ?

he is 5 years old, and he was with his mother all the time she was out of canada, can i renew his PR card since i am inline with the RO

 

[Bryanna]

how about my son's PR ?

he is 5 years old, and he was with his mother all the time she was out of canada, can i renew his PR card since i am inline with the RO

Your son has not met RO + he does not live in Canada

 

[Bryanna]

why the embassy is concerned of meeting RO, shouldnt that be the job of IRCC not embassy,

The embassy is part of IRCC.

even though , each PR have the right to enter Canada,at least to explain him/herself in the court..!!?

She will not be denied entry. However, she will most likely get reported for not meeting RO.

IMO, your wife does not have H&C grounds to retain her PR status