Justice Delayed is Justice Denied

December 8th, 2006

Hassan Samimifar is bitter, and it is hard to blame him for feeling that way.

Mr. Samimifar, an Iranian national, arrived in Canada 21 years ago and immediately applied for refugee status. Until 2003 he was waiting for an answer. When his file was finally addressed, his application was refused. After an immigration hearing scheduled for early December, Samimifar could be deported to Iran by early 2007.

Samimifar was told his application was refused because of alleged ties to a terrorist organization, a Marxist group called MEK which sought to overthrow the Iranian government. The Canadian government’s allegations stem from lectures and demonstrations he attended while he was a university student. Samimifar is now 47 and says he was never a member of the group, and has had no contact with them since arriving in Canada.

While delays can be expected from time to time, Samimifar has now spent nearly half of his life in legal limbo. Arguing that the wait has cost him some of the best years of his life, he is suing the Canadian government for $5 million in lost income and damages. That case is still before the courts.

Under Section 11 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, any person, regardless of citizenship status, has the right to have their case tried within a reasonable amount of time. This right has been clearly upheld and defined in criminal law, but immigration law in Canada falls under another category, administrative law. The spirit of the charter is still applicable here, as it refers only to “any person charged with an offence”. As the refusal of his application is based on an allegation of membership in a terrorist organization, this charter guarantee should apply. The law does not give Mr. Samimifar a right to be in Canada, it does however call for fair treatment.

We have to ask, what went wrong here? Some of the responsibility lay initially with Mr. Samimifar himself as he was convicted in 1986 of causing a disturbance after an altercation with immigration official, something that delayed his application for permanent residence. That can certainly explain some of the delay but not two decades. Mr. Samimifar’s application was approved in principle for permanent residence in 1994 but he would wait another 9 years for a decision, which would turn his application down.

By any stretch this could not be called a normal processing time. While the legal precedents apply specifically to criminal law, the spirit of justice and fairness dictates that Mr. Samimifar should be allowed to stay in Canada after the wait he has had to endure.

Previous Blog : Is It Time For An Amnesty?
Next Blog : New Beginnings

One Response to “Justice Delayed is Justice Denied”

  • On August 12th, 2009, freeedomwho? said ...

    Anyone coming to Canada does not have the automatic right to be accepted nor do they have the automatic right to come in, recieve welfare, healthcare, education, work training, language training etc., while they are waiting to be accepted.
    Canada has been and is very accomodating in fact to a fault with regard to immigration and refugee applications. This very department within our government is costing Canadians dearly and unfortunately we have apparently been a bit too lax in this very area as we have permitted too many undesirables roaming freely within our borders- most of whom the government isn't even aware are here but more disturbingly, how they got in here. Further once they arrive on our soil it not only costs millions of dollars to get them out if we don't want them here but apparently it is becoming almost impossible to get them out.
    We may be a country of freedom however this does not entitle everyone to come here and dictate to us whether or not they can stay. AS for the right to be heard in our courts within a reasonable time, my husband and I have a suit against a dishonest accountant who ended up costing us dearly with the revenue department and we have been waiting over 5 years for it to come to trial. Apprently we aren't important enough other than at tax time.
    We no longer own our home because of this either and as my husband works two jobs (has for 26 years so I could stay home and raise our children- although now I also work-and pay taxes) he is taxed to death as his incomes are combined at tax time= BIG TAXES and unfortunately NO CLAIMS!!
    Now we will have to work literally until we die if we hope to have a roof over our heads as we lost our RRSP's as well.
    Now, explain to me why we should be so worried about someone who decided Canada would be a wonderful place to live and because they haven't fully been accepted here yet they think we owe them millions of dollars???!

Leave a Reply

Go to Blog Home Page