CANADAVISA.com Immigration Forum
May 29, 2012, 09:13:41 am
   Home   Assessment Help Search Login Register RSS  
*
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Did you miss your activation email?

 News
 
Pages: [1]   Go Down
  Print  
Author Topic: procedure of filling an appeal against the decision taken by the visa officer  (Read 841 times)
deepak jaitly
Newbie
*

Posts: 1
Ratings: +0

« on: October 04, 2010, 11:34:44 am »

my case was passed by the DFM, Sydney, Nova Scotia, Canada.  I was directed to submit my full application to the Visa Officer New Delhi, INDIA.  I submitted my full application to the Visa Officer, New Delhi in time according to the instructions provided by the Official Webside for "Mailing your Application". But Visa Officer did not provide me any points for my Language Proficiency. I provided with  all my credentials pertaining my educational qualifications where are through and through obtained in English. The Official vebsite has mentioned TWO ways to prove Language Proficienct. One is by providing IELTS result AND other is to provide all the educational qualification in English and Work experience in English. Now I want to file an appeal with the Federal Court of Canada against the decision. I want to know the procedure that how can i file the appeal myself as i dont  want to engage any lawyer.
kindly guide me in this respect.
Logged
gte439u
Star Member
****

Posts: 158
Ratings: +11
Category........: FSW3
Visa Office......: Buffalo
NOC Code......: 41xx
Job Offer........: Yes
App. Filed.......: 28-SEP-2009
Doc's Request.: 01-DEC-2009
AOR Received.: 28-APR-2010
File Transfer...: In Process at Buffalo from 13-AUG-2010
Med's Request: 09-SEP-2010
Med's Done....: 24-SEP-2010
Passport Req..: 05-NOV-2010
VISA ISSUED...: 09-NOV-2010
LANDED..........: 09-NOV-2010

« Reply #1 on: October 04, 2010, 12:09:49 pm »

You may consider writing the IELTS exam, and then sending the results along with an explanation letter to the consulate.  You should also request the officer's reasons for not awarding you any points for languages.  This can be done with a CAIPS search.
Logged
captain74
Star Member
****

Posts: 74
Ratings: +3

« Reply #2 on: October 04, 2010, 01:10:01 pm »

Deepak

From personal experience, I think engaging a lawyer would be a good idea.

Firstly, I think only a lawyer can file a Judicial Review (technically, this is all you can ask for as appeals are not permitted on such decisions by immigration officers) application in the Federal Court  so you may not have much choice if a judicial review is the way you want to go (not absolutely sure on this point but pretty convinced this is the case).

Secondly, a good lawyer will probably be able to get matters resolved without the need to actually go to court. Also, I agree with gte439u that you should ask for CAPIS notes and take the IELTS ASAP as a back up should it come to that in your dialogue with the CHC. Both CAPIS and IELTS will probably help your lawyer get a favourable action without the need to go to court.

Finally - and this is just the way I personally operate so feel free to reject if you like - I think it might yield better results if you try to engage with CHC and explain how you meet all the requirements rather than try and prove (in a court) that they are wrong. Language proficiency assessment based on anything other than a recognised test is highly subjective and how you approach CHC could be crucial.

Good luck!

I want to know the procedure that how can i file the appeal myself as i dont  want to engage any lawyer.
kindly guide me in this respect.

Logged
johny gaddar
Star Member
****

Posts: 193
Ratings: +5
Category........: FSW1
Visa Office......: CHC ND
NOC Code......: 3142
App. Filed.......: 9th March 2010
Doc's Request.: 1st May2010
AOR Received.: 28th June 2010
IELTS Request: Already given - 7 bands
File Transfer...: 09th May 2010
Med's Request: waiting....

« Reply #3 on: October 04, 2010, 02:12:39 pm »

Dear Deepak....
Please don't involve in legal things...
It's better to write a letter stating that you are willing to take IELTS test as soon as possible....meanwhile request the VO to hold that application for you..

You can tell the VO that you have chosen the second option for proving language profiency because it is mentioned there...and there was no madate thing on IELTS requirement...

you can ask the VO for some 1-2 months extention...

and also write some good points about you to make them realize that you can be a potential immigrant..if you have given a chance to prove your language through IELTS...

I hope that this kind of approach might prove more helpful..rather going to LAW straight away...dont forget to apply that file sticker on your letter...all the best buddy!!
Logged

The great pleasure in life is doing what people say you cannot do...
beauhoe
Hero Member
*****

Posts: 876
Ratings: +37

« Reply #4 on: October 04, 2010, 03:05:11 pm »

my case was passed by the DFM, Sydney, Nova Scotia, Canada.  I was directed to submit my full application to the Visa Officer New Delhi, INDIA.  I submitted my full application to the Visa Officer, New Delhi in time according to the instructions provided by the Official Webside for "Mailing your Application". But Visa Officer did not provide me any points for my Language Proficiency. I provided with  all my credentials pertaining my educational qualifications where are through and through obtained in English. The Official vebsite has mentioned TWO ways to prove Language Proficienct. One is by providing IELTS result AND other is to provide all the educational qualification in English and Work experience in English. Now I want to file an appeal with the Federal Court of Canada against the decision. I want to know the procedure that how can i file the appeal myself as i dont  want to engage any lawyer.
kindly guide me in this respect.

Good job! Do not involve lawyers you can do this on your own. As some friends already suggested send a letter to your VO telling him that you are getting ready to take your IELTS. Show the VO that you are really interesting in coming and work in Canada and all your future depends on the visa. They are all human being and they will listen to your case.Cheers,
Logged
shubash
Hero Member
*****

Posts: 311
Ratings: +4
Category........: FSW1
Visa Office......: CHC New Delhi
NOC Code......: 0631
Pre-Assessed..: Yes
App. Filed.......: 29th Nov'2009
Doc's Request.: 6th Feb,2010
AOR Received.: 10th December
File Transfer...: Feb'2010
Med's Request: 28th June,2010
Med's Done....: 27th July,2010
Interview........: n/a
Passport Req..: 27th July,2010
VISA ISSUED...: waiting
LANDED..........: not decided

« Reply #5 on: October 04, 2010, 09:42:43 pm »

my case was passed by the DFM, Sydney, Nova Scotia, Canada.  I was directed to submit my full application to the Visa Officer New Delhi, INDIA.  I submitted my full application to the Visa Officer, New Delhi in time according to the instructions provided by the Official Webside for "Mailing your Application". But Visa Officer did not provide me any points for my Language Proficiency. I provided with  all my credentials pertaining my educational qualifications where are through and through obtained in English. The Official vebsite has mentioned TWO ways to prove Language Proficienct. One is by providing IELTS result AND other is to provide all the educational qualification in English and Work experience in English. Now I want to file an appeal with the Federal Court of Canada against the decision. I want to know the procedure that how can i file the appeal myself as i dont  want to engage any lawyer.
kindly guide me in this respect.



Hi,

Please do not appeal against the decision because it's just waste of time...My case was also rejected initially and appealed ... CHC replied saying they don't reconsider their decision..

3-4 months will be wasted. I suggest you to reapply and your process will be faster ..

Thanks

Shubash
Logged
waiting4pr
Hero Member
*****

Posts: 433
Ratings: +10
Category........: FSW3
Visa Office......: New Delhi
NOC Code......: 0213
Pre-Assessed..: Yes
App. Filed.......: 05-11-2008
Doc's Request.: 06-01-2010
AOR Received.: 28-10-2009,25-05-2010
IELTS Request: Not Required
File Transfer...: 03-05-2010
Med's Request: 03-08-2010
Med's Done....: 09-08-2010
Interview........: waived
Passport Req..: 03-08-2010 Sent on 10-08-2010
VISA ISSUED...: 27-08-2010
LANDED..........: Landed @Edmonton on 19/12/2010

« Reply #6 on: October 04, 2010, 10:38:42 pm »


Hi,

Please do not appeal against the decision because it's just waste of time...My case was also rejected initially and appealed ... CHC replied saying they don't reconsider their decision..

3-4 months will be wasted. I suggest you to reapply and your process will be faster ..

Thanks

Shubash

why ur case was rejected intially shubash?
Logged

In Process since 25th May 2010
Passport Sent on 10th Aug 2010.
Visa Issued on 27th Aug 2010
 Join us on facebook Group by name: May Applicants
shibuya
Champion Member
******

Posts: 1567
Ratings: +160
Category........: Other

« Reply #7 on: October 04, 2010, 10:51:21 pm »

IELTS is currently MANDATORY for all and that is the reason for rejection.
Logged
mis
Hero Member
*****

Posts: 431
Ratings: +13
Category........: FSW1
Visa Office......: LONDON
NOC Code......: 0111
App. Filed.......: 10-03-2010 - CC Charged on 16 June 2010
Doc's Request.: 17-06-2010
Nomination.....: 17-06-2010
AOR Received.: 17-06-2010
IELTS Request: 05-08-2010 Band 7
File Transfer...: London Acknowledgement 2nd AOR 31-01-2011
Med's Request: Waiting
Med's Done....: Waiting
Interview........: Waiting
Passport Req..: Waiting
VISA ISSUED...: Waiting
LANDED..........: Waiting

« Reply #8 on: October 04, 2010, 11:11:01 pm »

i remember its mentioned in some document that on language proficiency you wont get second chance if VO reject your application that is why they recommend everyone to give ielts.

but still try your luck write a letter to them and explain them the complete situation chances are very thin but still no harm in trying your luck dont involve lawyer. also mention that in your letter that you are giving ielts and update CIC ASAP.
Logged

Regards
MIS
Pages: [1]   Go Up
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Powered by SMF 1.1.10 | SMF © 2006-2009, Simple Machines LLC